Search results

  1. Some Dude

    What makes a successful superhero game?

    Which I totally get. My favorite superhero game is Golden Heroes. Not even because I think it's the "best" superhero game. I don't. But because it's the game that - for me - most captures the "feel" of my favorite comics as a kid (read: early '80s Marvel).
  2. Some Dude

    What makes a successful superhero game?

    If Aunt May can operate alongside the Avengers, Spider-Man becomes largely irrelevant. Traditionally, even games that can model a wide range of power/ability levels (think Champions or DC Heroes) have adventures that recommend a power level in actual play. So, yes, these characters can all...
  3. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    That's really all I was ever trying to say.
  4. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    To be honest, I haven't seen any evidence. Just an assumption that the folks at TSR who were involved with these awards, and with reviews, lacked integrity and/or were outright dishonest. I'm not trying to die on any hill. I'd love to be proven wrong, and would gladly admit it if I was. But so...
  5. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    Never implied that you were. And I have been looking for sources. But since you seemed to have some already, I saw no harm in asking. To be fair, you are the one making a claim by implication (i.e., that TSR staffers and magazines were not trustworthy when it came to reviews or awards), not I...
  6. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    Yes, and TSR was the most popular and successful game company at that time. Were the Gamers' Choice Awards similarly slanted towards TSR every year? Or just this year?
  7. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    You're being both pedantic and insulting, for no good reason. My point does stand, because I've never said that it got any "glowing" reviews. Merely that it wasn't as hated upon its release as it would become. And while I understand your cynicism wrt Dragon, I respect Ken Rolston's integrity...
  8. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    Yes, but let's not assume that the staffers and writers at Dragon were incapable of impartiality. Were the Gamers' Choice awards voted on by readers? My point stands. WG7 was not as hated upon its release as it would become in the decades that followed.
  9. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    In Dragon Magazine, Ken Rolston had some nice words to say about WG7: It also won the Gamer's Choice Award in Dragon Magazine #151 for "Best Role-Playing Adventure" in 1989. Time has not been kind to it, but it didn't always seem to be so reviled.
  10. Some Dude

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    With Strangers In Game Store
  11. Some Dude

    Itch.io is shadowbanning or deleting NSFW and LGBTQ content

    The forces, and in some cases the organizations behind The Satanic Panic of the '80s never truly went away. Changed targets and/or tactics, maybe. I'm of the opinion that you can draw a straight line from the moral panics of the '80s to those of today.
  12. Some Dude

    Itch.io is shadowbanning or deleting NSFW and LGBTQ content

    "We must take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim" -Elie Wiesel
  13. Some Dude

    Old shows that you enjoy?

    Strongest man in the kingdom!
  14. Some Dude

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    I had a brief interaction with Bill Webb a while back regarding this. I don't claim to have any privileged info, or know Webb. But he did say that he was under an NDA, but would love for Frog God's side of that story to come out, if not for that. Someone named Aaron Bledsaw, who said they...
  15. Some Dude

    Old shows that you enjoy?

    The old I Spy TV series holds up very well. It's been a favorite since I was a kid. I don't recommend it to people anymore, though, because Bill Cosby is in it. And there's just no getting around that ick. Wizards and Warriors was a short-lived series from 1983, that was partially inspired by...
  16. Some Dude

    Itch.io is shadowbanning or deleting NSFW and LGBTQ content

    I have been saying for a long time that the satanic panic never ended. Though it isn't starting with gaming this time, I figured it would eventually come back around.
  17. Some Dude

    What's Your Price Limit?

    I don't know that I have a "limit"," per se. I have spent as much as $250 on new stuff (The Fantasy Trip I Want It All Box) and on used stuff (various purchases). Haven't ever spent more than that, though.
  18. Some Dude

    Spoilers Superman Spoiler Thread

    Worth noting that post-Crisis Superman had considerably reduced powers. From Superman's inception, his power level has fluctuated wildly over time. Though we didn't get to see enough of Clark Kent in this, I think this movie did the best job of making them seem like two different people, and...
  19. Some Dude

    History Rhymes: Another Gygax Lawsuit

    IMHO, WG7 Castle Greyhawk isn't nearly as bad as its reputation suggests. Sure, it's a terrible Greyhawk module, but taken as its own thing, it's actually pretty good. Well, parts of it are. The three biggest criticisms I'd level at it are: -Some groaningly bad attempts at humor (there are...
  20. Some Dude

    Spoilers Superman Spoiler Thread

    Not a huge fan of superhero movies in general. I'd usually just rather read comic books, and inaccurate costumes tick me off. That's a me issue. So, I haven't watched a lot of comic movies as a result. I've watched some, and usually felt disappointed. Probably my favorite comic book movie was...
Top