Search results

  1. Professor Murder

    D&D General Why Do People Hate Gnomes?

    In one of my campaigns to explain Gnomes I had that just at one point they appeared and integrated into nearby elf (Forest Gnome) and Dwarf (Rock Gnome) communities, taking on their culture for the most part. It was revealed later that these gnomes were descendants of dissident Deep Gnomes...
  2. Professor Murder

    D&D General Why Do People Hate Gnomes?

    I had a bad experience.
  3. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) When do you hide and when do you reveal DCs?

    So this came up at my game this week and it has me thinking. When do you reveal the DC for a roll made by the PCs? Do you tell them say AC or the DC for a saving throw or skill check before the roll? After the roll? Wait until after the encounter is over? Not reveal at all, just success or...
  4. Professor Murder

    Wizards of the Coast Employees Walk Out Over Hasbro's 'Tone-Deaf' Response to Overturning of Roe v. Wade

    I am just curious to know if anyone can point out the inciting "tone deaf" response by Hasbro. As a rule, corporate messaging on contentious political issues means a lot less to me than how said corporation may be funding political causes behind the scenes. Don't tell me you find these rulings...
  5. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Caution in Too Much Fun

    I guess this can be a goal at small tables. I have six players at my current table. In combats, when it's not a given player's turn, it's gonna be boring. That's gonna happen. Its why I advocate for anything that can reasonably help speed combat up.
  6. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Caution in Too Much Fun

    These are good points. No activity at your table will please everyone at all times. An after action report, even just asking for simple feedback, can help identify what sorts of game activities draw in the people at your table. More my point was, unless everyone at the table enjoys a given...
  7. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Caution in Too Much Fun

    The game that gives Rolemaster a run for its money in terms of achingly earnest complexity? Not so much, no.
  8. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Caution in Too Much Fun

    Again, mild hyperbole, but yeah, the shopping RP is the most tedious part of the show. I would argue that, when we talk about pacing, no singular sort of RP experience should be four hours at a stretch. For example, even if it was the epic conclusion to an entire, years long campaign, I would...
  9. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Caution in Too Much Fun

    I would hope "4 hours shopping RP" is hyperbole, because please lord no.
  10. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Bring Back THAC0 !!! (not serious - read the OP)

    This is my experience at the time also.
  11. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Bring Back THAC0 !!! (not serious - read the OP)

    Real talk: The game should be further reducing needless complexity to speed up combat. Bounded accuracy and less bonuses overall ahs been a boon to running combats more smoothly and quickly.
  12. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Bring Back THAC0 !!! (not serious - read the OP)

    The only reason to have THAC0 return would be to make the kids have to learn algebra at an early age like I did.
  13. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Grey beard culture question about critical role

    I think there is something to be said that, broad strokes, there are generational divides in gaming culture. I say this as someone who has been gaming for around 40 yrs and really doesn't click with what seems to be the attitude of most long term gamers online. All that said, for most gamers...
  14. Professor Murder

    Free RPG Day 2022 – The Offerings

    Hunter 5e has my attention at least.
  15. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Using Downtime Training new ways

    I'm not so worried about the systems. I would just expand on the existing framework and have it take more time. I'm more curious as to how good/bad an idea it may be. Like, on one hand, gaining a new skill or feat is powerful. On the other hand, if it takes say 15-20 downtime actions (DTA) to...
  16. Professor Murder

    D&D 5E (2014) Using Downtime Training new ways

    So as written, you can use Downtime to train, learning languages and tool skills. I am debating expanding this to allow for "normal" skills or even feats. Looking for some feedback.
  17. Professor Murder

    Out with the old (Game design traditions we should let go)

    Combat being a distinct and separate system for resolving conflict/solving problems.
  18. Professor Murder

    How faithful should a culture be adapted in an RPG?

    So the first question is, are you creating a game that is a historical or semi-historical recreation or are you engaged in pastiche? Example: A game inspired by the Vikings is likely to include the act that they are named for, namely raiding other communities, which would historically involve...
  19. Professor Murder

    D&D General Testing Players

    For DnD? No. For a LARP. Yes.
Top