Search results

I'm baffled that they are still so reluctant to use a version of Battlemaster warlord type manoeuvres for Bannerets. Even if you scaled back the dice to 1d6 or reduced the number of manoeuvres or dice by half. Given that some might argue balance, my tweak will probably be to give them a free...

I interspersed some Living Greyhawk modules and some of the Rod of Seven parts (but the still don't have part 6). They are just about to assist in the second siege of Gorna so I think we will power through the last 6 modules dealing with the giants before going back to AoW. Maybe it's the...

I believe in 1e, only fighters, rangers, and paladins - all of whom were likely to already have strength 16+ - could use the belts.

What we're finding is more that Barbarians have more hp and more ways to preserve those hp. Toughness will help but can be taken by anyone. I would have preferred fighters to have had an ability called Tactical Withdrawal where they can impose disadvantage on opportunity attacks and (at...

I'm not obsessed with stats to be honest - I just think fighters need more HP. All I'm saying is that there should an option with mechanical benefits for players who fancy playing an intelligent, non-magical fighter. Fighters shouldn't be forced to be stupid because that 14 really should go...

I'm not sure I want more dex feats but yeah, something like that. At-will commander's strike might be a bit much when you consider the other option is one manoeuvre per short rest but you could certainly allow it a number of times per short rest equal to your intelligence modifier without bonus...

Exactly. All magical. I do view psionics as a form of magic, just not arcane magic. Certainly, they aren't purely martial. A player wanting a martial character who is intelligent should have an option without being magical. The tactical warlord in 4e showed that there is an archetype that...

I'm not familiar with any intelligence based fighter subclasses that aren't also spell-casters. I would love more variation in martial classes. Back in 1e, half the group would be martial, largely due to variations of fighters anf fighter thieves, although rangers also started out as martial...

Personally I would like to see options to encourage both like in 4e. Adding half int bonus rounded up to initiative and persuasion might discourage total stat dumping. Adding Charisma to second wind healing might be an alternative. I think there needs to be more reason for non wizards not to...

I felt that giving them the d6 superiority dice plus the manoeuvre that boosted cha checks and one other warlord style manoeuvre instead of proficiency in persuasion would be a start. Can supplement at higher levels and with feats. Their other class features are not like battlemasters at all.

Yes, coin a phrase from A5E, you could grant an expertise die on melee damage and boost the die up the ranks 1d4 ogres up to 1d12 Storm without affecting attack rolls but that isn't qualitatively that different to +4 to strength. Maybe charges per day for certain feats of strength is better.

Bannerets should have access to warlord type battlemaster manoeuvres with d6 dice. They could have a class feature that let's them make diplomacy rolls to communicate even where intelligent beings lack a common language. To be fair, I'd prefer to let anybody try this up to a point.

Living Greyhawk used meta organisations, a bit like factions, which had benefits depending on your standing within the organisation independent of class or background. A Knight who rides a dragon sounds to me like it should be independent of class. Paladin mounts have always been a bit of a...

Your mileage may vary. A lot of players love stat boost items. If all a girdle of giant strength does is boost your carrying capacity, you might not engage players as much with an iconic magic item.

If you want to re-design the other stat-boost items you just need to pick alternative riders. Headband of Intellect can be +2 intelligence (max 21) and the wearer gains proficiency (or expertise if already proficient) in Arcana, History, Nature, and Religion. Pearl of Wisdom +2 (max 21) and...

The way I have done it was inspired by the difference between enhanced strength and super strength from Mutants and Masterminds. Gauntlets of Ogre Power: +2 strength (max 19); treat wearer as large for the purposes of carrying and feats of strength related to size (such as pushing or...

I have been frustrated that classic shadow spells have been so absent, almost like they were deliberately saving them for a supplement that never happened. I get that shadow conjuration and evocation were too broad for 5e but I have seen some fan content, which used class features to try and...

I have always hated the notion that rogues can double dash. They're already incredibly mobile and I would prefer them to use their bonus action imaginatively. The cinematic tradition is pulling over a stall of melons to create difficult terrain, not sprint like Usain Bolt. There are other ways...

The change was clearly brought in to overcome the notion that you can be seen by everyone as soon as you break cover rather than allowing the obvious trope of being able to sneak up behind people or past distracted people. They should have put in a small amount of clarification. You can...

Most monsters are not that hard to find. I do think there is design space for rebalancing the passive scores. I would say anyone performing any other task while exploring, such as moving stealthily, should be base 5. Not allowing expertise bonuses on passive scores would help, and allowing...