Search results

  1. Campbell

    What Do You Think Of As "Modern TTRPG Mechanics"?

    When I think about intentional design I think about designers having a clear vision of what they want the game to be about, not just from a setting/fiction perspective but also as a game. Then the proceed from first principles instead of assuming there are things you need to include because they...
  2. Campbell

    What is/are your most recent TTRPG purchase(s)?

    Pledged for physical copies of Fabula Ultima Core Rulebook and Bestiary.
  3. Campbell

    Will the complexity pendulum swing back?

    @Reynard I do not think a game needs to be structured like X-Com or Final Fantasy Tactics to be tactical. I consider a game tactical if it has a compelling combat system that can be played skillfully, requires coordination and skill at execution time is the determining factor in success. I...
  4. Campbell

    Will the complexity pendulum swing back?

    Note that I do not think grids are universal here. Some use square grids (Draw Steel, Cosmere). Some use hex grids (Lancer). Others use zones (Warhammer - The Old World), range bands (L5R) and some even use completely narrative positioning (Fabula Ultima). The other unifying theme for me (on a...
  5. Campbell

    Will the complexity pendulum swing back?

    The games I consider modern tactical games share the following characteristics (though some might miss a point or two): What Makes Them Tactical? An emphasis on in the moment execution over character building or logistics. Skill at playing the game is expressed in the moment and the feedback...
  6. Campbell

    Million Dollar TTRPG Kickstarter Club

    For Fabula Ultima in particular it means the game is about heroic fantasy narratives with a strong emphasis on found family and discovering who you are deep down. This is embedded in its Fabula Points reward cycle.
  7. Campbell

    Will the complexity pendulum swing back?

    So one of the interesting the form of more moderate crunch games in the last 10 or so years. Games like GURPS, Champions, Shadowrun, Mutants and Masterminds, Pathfinder et al are highly granular games that leave no stone unturned. No detail is too small to consider. Games like Lancer, Draw...
  8. Campbell

    Will the complexity pendulum swing back?

    Almost all Powered by the Apocalypse games Almost all Forged in the Dark games The 5th Edition World of Darkness games Almost all 2d20 games from Modiphius (Conan and Infiniti being the exception) Cortex games like Tales of Xadia, Marvel Heroic Roleplay and Smallville The Cinematic Unisystem...
  9. Campbell

    D&D General The Great Railroad Thread

    My experience from playing in other GMs games and what I hear from most people in my circles and see online are that most people play in fairly linear games. I also have experienced that a lot of players assume the GM is supposed to provide them with a story/adventure and have trouble coming up...
  10. Campbell

    Which "Tactical" TTRPG Would Work Best As An X-Com Like?

    Draw Steel does. Very detailed project rules and you get followers as you get reputation to help with projects. Pretty easy to make that get attached R&D support as you earn recognition in the company.
  11. Campbell

    What gets me playing Draw Steel and not Pathfinder 2e?

    Just got done running the Road To Broadhurst. We had a blast. For a game with so many new mechanics we picked up real easy. From a GM's perspective the monsters were a lot of fun and super easy to manage. Malice spends felt really fun and added a lot of dynamism. The Fury moved enemies all over...
  12. Campbell

    D&D General The Great Railroad Thread

    I cannot comment on anyone's particular D&D game. It's quite possible to run games in a Narrativist even if they are supported by the game's mechanics. Most of us have done so from time to time, though often with certain features of mechanics kind of getting in the way. I'm mostly just...
  13. Campbell

    D&D General The Great Railroad Thread

    What sustaining the momentum of play looks like will vary from game to game. The premise we are exploring will usually involve but might not always center on them or their desires specifically. For instance the conflicts Apocalypse Keys is centered on are mysteries that pit the characters...
  14. Campbell

    D&D General The Great Railroad Thread

    I present a dynamic situation where some ball is about to roll down some hill and ask players what their characters are going to do about it. Then together we all see how that situation resolves based on what they do. By no agenda I mean that I don't have any aims for how the situation must...
  15. Campbell

    What gets me playing Draw Steel and not Pathfinder 2e?

    Yeah. I really appreciate them trying to make the Conditions in the game more interactive which I think should be more fun for both players and GMs. The lose your turn stuff is never really fun and not very tactical either.
  16. Campbell

    What is/are your most recent TTRPG purchase(s)?

    Draw Steel - Core Rulebook Set, An extra copy of Heroes, preordered a Vampire class supplement. Backed Cypher System on Backerkit (Player Core, GM Core, Bestiary).
  17. Campbell

    D&D General The Great Railroad Thread

    That is definitely not a sentiment most anyone who is a fan of Narrativist play would agree with. The most central principle is something along the lines of "be a curious explorer of the fiction" or "keep the story feral". The basic idea is that the GM sets the scene but once the scene is set we...
  18. Campbell

    What gets me playing Draw Steel and not Pathfinder 2e?

    For players who are less interested in tactical play I think managing your abilities is actually going to be the less tricky part. The trickier part is that Draw Skill is a game where monsters will be pushing you around, inflicting conditions on you, creating difficult terrain, raising up walls...
  19. Campbell

    D&D General The Great Railroad Thread

    I do not think railroading is very useful to discuss because we are often avoiding where the root of the issue is. Complaints about railroading usually come down to issues with blocking or issues with story advocacy (making decisions based on how you want fictional events to play out). Those of...
  20. Campbell

    Draw Steel General Thread [+]

    I think the bigger question here is "What does a Weapon Master do in negotiations, in montages, in intrigue scenes, in exploration scenes?" that is distinct from the Tactician and how are they a weapon master in a way that does not take a way conceptually from the Tactician. I'm not saying...
Top