Search results

I feel I can't agree with this until you define what Main Street needs to do to "do well" in your estimation. Make as much money as WotC? IMO that's an impossible standard unless WotC takes a major hit in popularly/sales. There are plenty of successful non-WotC games out there right now, they...

If both are true it would be pretty intense from my perspective. "My PC cannot die unless I say so, and I will if you, the evil GM, allow any long-term harm to befall them". Honestly that's not a game I want to run.

I feel like long-term/indefinite injuries and conditions can work, provided some way to fix them is potentially available, even if special and/or expensive resources have to be gathered for it. Otherwise, if you're right, it seems you are saying that a player would rather have their PC die than...

That can work, provided they want to play something more narrative in the first place.

I have that book. Really interesting! I need to try it sometime.

That would lead to speculation on what the Iron Age of RPGs will be like...

For me there are two: the period from 1989 to about 2000 or so, when the bulk of the game I have the fondest memories of flourished (AD&D 2e, Cyberpunk 2020, Marvel Superheroes, L5R, Deadlands, among others), and now, when so many great alternatives to WotC 5e exist.

Yeah. I've had a few close calls and one PC death recently, but I've never had a TPK since I started playing A5e. My players handle themselves pretty well.

Did the other DM also have a problem with TPKs?

That's too bad. I love 2e. Best version of the game IMO.

Very much so. Easy for me though. The only person likely to keep with what's new in WHRPGs (or RPGs in general) is me.

Do you think they'll assume everyone will switch over once the new staff's out? That happens sometimes.

Not me. Bring on more content! I had a ton of fun with WHFRPG 1e and 2e. Had a bunch of books for 2e in particular back in the day.

I would be interested in a reissue of 1e. Don't have a physical copy of that game.

Bad luck. Did the paladin not see what happened to the rogue? Seems they could have potentially waited for the rogue to do their thing before walking in.

A game is done by default whenever they stop making it, but generally I'll keep buying a game I like so long as it is recognizably the same game (or can become so with a little work). L5R is a good example. I bought everything for that game from 1e to 2e, d20 (still based on a game I liked)...

Yeah, I don't believe "sports" and "rpg" are the same level of generalization (though both generalize of course).

Of course, not every RPG uses these labels to describe their game, and the biggest one kinda uses all of them, so confusion and clashing expectations still happen pretty regularly IME. I know I have to be clear when I run a game about my desires for simulationist sandbox play, while still being...

Fair enough. Why do you think that is? Are you running challenges beyond the level guidelines? Are your players not making good tactical choices? Are they getting into situations they can't get out of?

Do you really run a serious risk at your table of killing all your characters in regular play? That's rough. My PCs are rarely in serious danger of getting killed (although one did die a couple days ago).