Search results

you're extrapolating 'logical and reasoned decisions' far too far down the chain of consequence.

the quoted sentence continues beyond the part you bolded you know: it's not asking for pure logical constructs of rationality, it's asking for characters who make smart well-reasoned decisions that make sense for the circumstances they find themselves in, the information available to them and...

my character having red hair is not something that is ever going to have any notable tangible effect on how things are likely to resolve and thus i don't feel needs to be codified into the mechanics, their species however, a factor on which my choice of is placed a non-insignificant amount of...

i wasn't referring to the act of roleplaying being a lie, i was referring to the truth of the nature of the character, claiming your character is something that the truth of the mechanics don't align with. for some people, that extra proficiency does matter and does make it less of a lie...

for a non-insignificant amount of people having those specialized mechanics is what allows them to play a mixed ancestry character without it feeling like a barefaced lie.

and they could've even done the half-elf story with 3 dwarf mechanics or no mechanics at all, doesn't mean they should've.

even if you aren't going to die for failure it can still carry consequences, as well as the fact that for some failing just isn't fun,

maybe, but i wasn't claiming it was THE most iconic catchphrase, just one of them. also, in hindsight i don't think 'catchphrase' exactly the right terminology but i can't think of what the right word is.

which is honestly such a shame IMO, since nearly day 1 one of the most iconic catchphrases of DnD was always 'pick your class and race species' but they're not even in the same league anymore. tangential general question not just to defcon, do you consider species abilities that are weaker but...

if presented with this issue my solution as hypothetical GM would be to try cobble together a new half-elf based off the mechanics of '24 humans and elves something like HALF-ELF '24 Size - Medium Speed - 30ft Resourceful - you gain heroic inspiration after a long rest Fey Ancestry - you have...

i agree with this but not so much the rest of your post, HM can burn in a fire for all i care but that's besides the point. pick dragons as your favoured enemy and you get advantage on saves against breath weapons and similar AoE monster attacks, you get a special anti-flying knockdown effect...

this is why i think they ought to be putting more heft into species and background options, to mitigate those sparse first few levels with features from other parts of the character without worrying about creating powerful multiclass dips from frontloaded classes.

look at it this way, cancelling the date as a result of failing your test isn't a consequence of failing your test because you didn't get the date in the first place as a result of you taking the test. your date didn't say 'if you pass your driving test i'll go on a date with you'

because attacking the orc is actually dependent to the character's skill and is a non-fixed outcome, whereas deciphering what the runes say is different because the runes shouldn't change depending on who reads them, what they want them to say, or how skilled they are at reading them. if i hand...

many of us who are taking this stance i believe, (though i cannot be able to claim to speak for everyone,) have this opinion from the position of a player just as much as a GM, it doesn't matter what side of the table we're sitting on what matters to us is how the game is played and the fiction...

oh but it does affect what something actually is, a character can hope for something and if the dice or GM indulge, it will be that thing, their hopes can and do influence the reality they exist in.

but hope can never and has never changed what something actually is, my friend buys me a birthday present, i can hope til the cows come home for the box to contain this thing or that thing, but it's going to have diddly squat effect on what they actually got me or what the runes on the wall...

i have to at least agree with @EzekielRaiden point with this particular bit, just using the spells you already know how to cast, no matter in how many varied situations, is not experimenting with them or going to teach the wizard anything new, that's like saying if i 'experiment' cooking...

just on a personal level, i do not care about having a combat companion, i like find familiar more for the scouting and eavesdropping purposes.

i would guess that, to my knowledge of them, it's because they're often used to (at the very least attempt to) manipulate or bypass the usual gameplay mechanics to achieve a desired outcome and get the story going in the direction you want it to as a result,