Search results

At this point it seems like everyone is going around in circles. @GreyLord doesn't like the Starter Set for whatever reason, so just let them be annoyed by it and they can use the original 5E Starter Set or Essentials Set going forward. They're just one person with a table of players who may...

Options: - Accept you are going to find barely any secret doors and travel through the dungeon as far as you can just on the normal pathways. Once you are done, leave the dungeon and come back later if you really need to get through those secret doors for whatever reason. - Rather than trying...

The whole original post seems odd. I mean why the heck is each player receiving their own entire Starter Set to begin with? That's like wanting to play Settlers of Catan and buying a separate copy of the game for every player rather than just playing the game for the four players that are...

It was always a "fantasy heartbreaker". It was never not one. Because every fantasy RPG that comes about and is designed purely in response to the game of Dungeons & Dragons and has some aspect of that game the designer wishes worked differently... is by definition a "fantasy heartbreaker"...

True true. The only real difference with Eberron was that it was specifically stated as part of its setting mentality that it was not meant to have many (if any) high-level characters, which means its own design paradigm was not really good for D&D as a game itself. ;) It'd be a better...

True enough, but I was thinking more of the adventures that would lead into Eyes at 5th level, and I believe Grasp was a 7th level adventure (which is why I didn't include it in my particular list.) But most definitely it could be possible to run a pseudo-adventure path using those four Eberron...

The longest Eberron adventure actually published by WotC in dead-tree form is Eyes of the Lich Queen. A 3.5 adventure that starts at 5th level and would take you probably to 10th or so (depending on the DM ad how they award XP or milestone it.) The adventure begins in Q'Barra I believe, so if...

And that's precisely why I made my post without quoting anybody, as though suggesting that person was wrong.

And that's the problem. 9th level wizards and other characters exist, but they are few and far between and you might only meet one of them out of every 500 NPCs you meet. Whereas we have a band of five of them all walking around together as a super-team. Meaning that they as a group...

Which I will not.

Yep. Exactly. That's really the advantage that was theoretically gained by the Dragonmarked Houses-- 99.999% of the populace might have at best up to 3rd level spells... but the House members who exhibited the more powerful dragonmarks would give those individuals the 5th, 6th, 7th level...

For me it comes down to the reason for the group taking the journey in the first place. Are they going somewhere else because they have something they very much want or need to do at that new location? If so... then what the players want is to get to that location and start in on the adventure...

Because for 99% of the time they are going to be useful and much easier to adjudicate than improvising everything. But that doesn't mean you should ever be beholden to them. Improvising or making up a ruling for one thing DOES NOT mean we therefore should just do it for everything. And it is...

If it's as mundane of a usage as that, then there's even less of a need to stop him from trying it. You can get practically the same information from a Perception check and not even spend a spell slot while doing it, LOL! :D

Does the door the player plans to talk to have something interesting and compelling to say? Will it drive the party's actions forward in the campaign? Will it be fun or funny? If it is any of those things... then I say yes absolutely. If we are good with PCs talking with other people, or...

With the expansion of the location/setting in Curse of Strahd (as opposed to the much shorter/quicker plotline in the original I6 Ravenloft module) the Ireena storyline can actually end up being minimized for a lot of groups and their playthroughs just based on what the players end up focusing...

I LOVE Eberron as a setting and have run a pair of campaigns there before... but I have always known of and have had to try and reconcile the one fatal flaw of the setting: Eberron is meant to be a wide setting when it comes to magic-- magic is everywhere and everyone uses it in their everyday...

As far as 5E was concerned... they wanted a Finesse weapon that could do 1d8 damage. But to make sure that level of Dexterity-based dual-wielding did not overpower the other fighting styles they made several hoops to jump through in order to get there-- made it a martial weapon, required...

And that's why you've chosen a game to play that in theory gives you that.

Sure! Good starting point and oftentimes would be worthwhile... but it never needs to be a hard and fast rule. If someone gets hit with a Poison attack first round and then an Acid attack second round and then a Radiant attack third... the one that causes the most damage or came off a crit or...