Search results

  1. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2024) D&D Preview at Garycon

    For some reason, red seems like a very “D&D” color to me. And with it being the 50th anniversary, gold is a fitting color choice. I wouldn’t mind seeing a cover depicting a fire(breath)fight between a red dragon and a gold dragon.
  2. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) Quest From The Infinite Staircase Adventures Revealed

    Saltmarsh and Yawning Portal came out before Explorers Guide to Wildemount, but I’ll have to wait until I get home from work to check if Golden Vault has any Exandria suggestions. If my memory serves me correctly, which it rarely does, I don’t think it had any for that setting.
  3. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) Quest From The Infinite Staircase Adventures Revealed

    I guess it’s too much for me to hope for suggested locations in Exandria 😢 It looks like I’ll have to do it myself like I did for Yawning Portal.
  4. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) How game-breaking is it if GW Fighting Style applies to smites?

    I don’t want to speak for the OP, but maybe they meant “if you make the bonus attack from GWM, can you smite on it too?” Or maybe the OP misunderstood what their player was asking 🤷🏻‍♂️
  5. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) How game-breaking is it if GW Fighting Style applies to smites?

    I don’t know why you would think that when the OP specifically mentioned “damage bonus” in the first paragraph and “feat” in the second paragraph.
  6. Gorck

    Critical Role's 'Daggerheart' Open Playtest Starts In March

    Yes, you can carry a third Weapon in your inventory as your Inventory Weapon (below the "Inventory" section of your character sheet). But, in order to make your Inventory Weapon become your Active Primary or Secondary Weapon, you would need to erase each of the two weapons and re-write their...
  7. Gorck

    Critical Role's 'Daggerheart' Open Playtest Starts In March

    A slight nitpick: I don't really like the way the Active Weapons and Inventory Weapons are listed on the character sheet. Say my Warrior has a Longsword and Dagger as his Primary and Secondary weapons and a Greatsword as his Inventory weapon. If I decide I want to switch to using my...
  8. Gorck

    Critical Role's 'Daggerheart' Open Playtest Starts In March

    Oh, I would try to run it “by the book” at first. But I can foresee it quickly spiraling out of control as three 12 year old girls yelled over each other trying to take their actions all at the same time, and me trying to rein them in and discern what each of them was saying. Or, if I turn out...
  9. Gorck

    Critical Role's 'Daggerheart' Open Playtest Starts In March

    Conversely, I was thinking about how this "non-Initiative" combat would port over to D&D. My initial thoughts were: 1) During combat, players can act at any time that makes sense for the story. 2) If a player makes an attack roll and the result on the d20 is <10, a random enemy gets to take...
  10. Gorck

    Critical Role's 'Daggerheart' Open Playtest Starts In March

    A) I said, " I think if I ever run . . ." It's not set in stone. B) I know myself and my players, and I can see how a lack of initiative order would be utterly chaotic and disruptive to our play experience.
  11. Gorck

    Critical Role's 'Daggerheart' Open Playtest Starts In March

    I think if I ever run this game with my group I will institute the following houserule: Initiative: At the start of combat, each player rolls their Duality Dice and adds their Agility modifier to determine the order of combat. If a player Rolls with Hope, they still mark a Hope slot. If a...
  12. Gorck

    D&D General Social Pillar Mechanics: Where do you stand?

    I fall on the side of “roll playing.” My character might be a smooth talking Bard with an 18 Charisma, but IRL I probably have a Charisma under 10. I’d hate to have my character suffer for my personal inabilities. That’s why my character has Charisma-based skills in the first place. The...
  13. Gorck

    D&D General Explain Bounded Accuracy to Me (As if I Was Five)

    In my old 3rd edition group, our DM had us do that. It was very terrifying trying not to die again with my new, weak character. But eventually I'd work my way back up to within a level or 2 of the rest of the party. In my current 5 edition group (where I'm the DM), we've yet to have a...
  14. Gorck

    D&D General Explain Bounded Accuracy to Me (As if I Was Five)

    Why not? Different DMs handle replacing dead characters differently. Some have the player create a new character at the same level, or one level lower, than the average party level. Others have the player create a first level character and work their way up. The latter approach would take...
  15. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) Should DnDBeyond include an Encounter Simulator?

    The old Kobold Fight Club might be defunct, but there’s a new one: https://koboldplus.club/#/encounter-builder
  16. Gorck

    D&D General "March Madness" - Let's Rank The D&D Classes

    I totally, 100% agree. (Because swapping them would mean my favorites, Rogue & Barbarian, would no longer be going head-to-head)
  17. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) What new content do you like most?

    I’m pretty simple: I chose Classes, Subclasses, and Species (Races).
  18. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) Alchemical Savant and Greenflame Blade

    The thought of rolling 1d4 for Magic Missile and using it as the damage for each missile seems as strange to me as casting Fireball, rolling 1d6, and then multiplying the result by 8 to get the total damage. But maybe that’s just me. I’ve been playing D&D off and on for over twenty years and...
  19. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) Alchemical Savant and Greenflame Blade

    The funny thing about RAW vs. RAI is that anyone can read RAW since it’s written right there for all to read. But only someone like Jeremy Crawford can tell us RAI, since he worked on the design of the rules. For Magic Missiles, I disagree with his RAW because the Damage Rolls section on page...
  20. Gorck

    D&D 5E (2014) Alchemical Savant and Greenflame Blade

    Which of the 8 UAs is that in? I can’t seem to find it anywhere.
Top