Search results

in terms of high level selling worse, absolutely

no, it’s not 10M PHB 2014, but 6-7M is in line with the around 1.6M that Bookscan is aware of. The factor of 10+ is for the 2024 books, not 2014

don’t think I ever read that, I certainly do not recall it. Are you confusing this with what happened between Raistlin and Fistandantilus?

not sure what is ironic about it. You take the estimate you arrived at and divide it by the Bookscan numbers, that is how you get to the factor of 4 or 5. It is not based on the Bookscan numbers but it shows how far off they are…...

I just explained it, he made a video about how bad 2024 is selling because it only sold 3k copies in its first month (according to Bookscan). That number is so obviously wrong that him making a whole video just regurgitating it as a fact to me shows that he has zero critical thinking skills...

Teos has a guy who has been doing this for years now, so they are used to looking into Hasbro figures and refined their approach. I do not trust Glicker at all after his Bookscan stunt. Someone who reports blatantly obvious nonsense like the PHB selling 3k copies in its first month lacks basic...

Hasbro does not break out D&D figures, sometime they say it grew by x%, but that is about it, so you will have to do some math to get to a somewhat reliable range. I’d go with Teos’ conclusions over Glicker’s Fastest selling when you count the first n months, probably (?) not fastest selling...

your answer is in my quote, so I could not quote it “Yes, he mentioned the 100K and that came from Bookscan, However, at one point he mentioned that, unlike with 2014, Bookscan's figures for 2024 are unreliable” they are also unreliable for 2014, they are probably off by a factor of 4 or 5...

so where is the 100k from then? they pretty much always do that, Hasbro does not like to share meaningful information not gonna watch the guy, do you have a summary of his analysis? Teos Abadia usually dives into these quarterly reports to figure out D&D sales. There was some podcast recently...

to figure out D&D sales numbers it is literally useless, I might as well guess them myself, I at least have a chance to get close, Bookscan does not. If you want to compare PHB24 to DMG24 ratio maybe it can work for that, not even sure about that

yes, the guy has no idea what he is talking about, Bookscan numbers are useless for D&D sales

I think I recently heard on a podcast that Kelsey sold 50k print copies of it

I am glad nothing is over level 13, lower levels get a lot more use out of these small scenarios

that is my problem with those bare bones adventure outlines. If I need to do 90% of the work to make it interesting, what good is it to have gotten those 10% from WotC

you mean you are not using up the spell slot? No, that is even worse than what we have now, the boss used a LR and you just cast the spell again

and Intoxication Monk sounds better to them? Who are these people?

still on the fence myself, but that is a step up from little interest ;) Will see what more in depth reports have to say

Here’s to hoping they do this for their other settings too… art looks great

I don’t think I was bashing the designers, I certainly did not say they do not know what they are doing. From my perspective I did three things 1) disagreed with the claim that WotC does not innovate at all, 2) said they are not particularly innovative and that market leaders pretty much never...

no, they did not say which ones, only that some made it but were dropped regardless if it made it past the UA threshold, it was not a popular veto, was it? How was that veto determined if not by the 70% approval threshold, was there like a 10% ‘hate it’ threshold too? Given that they said that...