Search results

That all makes sense. I couldn’t play this way with NPC agendas and goals out on the table upfront because for me that destroys investigation and mystery. Part of the enjoyment of roleplaying is discovering these things and working out how they fit together through my enquiries and roleplaying...

That’s really funny. My group went a completely different way and didn’t see any of those places!

So the core advantage rules were designed to create a sense of momentum in combat. Earlier editions were accused for being to whiffly - you could spend round after round ineffectually whaling on your opponent to no avail. Instead advantage meant every time you won an opposed test you would gain...

@Retreater did you use any of the guides and which locations did you find most interesting?

So much good stuff here. Specifically on the death curse I couldn’t agree more. I figured it could be something afflicting the continent primarily - a good origin story for monsters, reason players can’t be resurrected normally and general malaise giving Chult a bit of a grimdark vibe. Then at...

I get that. Makes sense. These add a lot of depth to NPCs. Make running NPCs much easier and give the PCs lots or interact with. So much so that I don’t think they need to be mutually exclusive with Map&Key or Events. Rather they would enhance any structure they are used in.

Back in 3e and Pathfinder 1 the many varied afflictions: poisons, diseases, curses, life draining, aging etc were generally handled though ability score damage either temporary or permanent. Purple worm poison will reduce your Constitution score, filth fever reduces your Dex and so on. 5e has...

So Foundry has released Tomb of Annihilation as a module for D&D a couple of weeks back and I am seriously considering running the campaign again online. I love Foundry and the tools it gives me as a DM. I ran it Face to Face when it first came out and felt it was definitely a cracking...

I think this will be good for Paizo and good for 5e. Abomination Vaults wouldn’t have been my choice because I’m not a fan of dungeon crawling but after this and Kingmaker, I hope they continue. Even if I’m not playing on beyond, having access to the maps and tokens in a digital format is still...

Those all sound like goals or motivations. Is that a fair way of characterizing the description you just gave? For instance an NPC I ran on Tuesday night. Wanted to find out what happened to her missing husband Was scared of and wanted to avoid the watch (In this case the PCs) Was scared of...

What are some of the quirks would you change in a 4.5? I won’t lie, the quirkiness is a feature not a bug for me, but I am interested as to what you would change? You’re totally right on the books. I’m using a lot of the stuff from Lustria for my next run through of Tomb of Annihilation. The...

So there are a few things I would say to this. Firstly, modifiers based on choices/environmental factors are amazing. They turn combat from two groups of folks wailing on each other to a game of tactical choices, where it’s not just about stripping wounds off folks as fast as they can. I use...

Sorry, despite quoting the rules I still don’t know what a ‘best interest’ is? I get that they should be used to target PCs but what are they? I’m not trying to be obtuse. The phrase itself is somewhat ambiguous. I feel like the quoted test seems to assume I know what this phrase should mean.

It’s so much fun. I really love this product. It would be cross system but so much of the fluff works well with a product like Dragon Heist or Keys from the Golden Vault.

I get that you have framed your argument in relation to a specific type of map/key style or event style. But these are the examples you have selected. By choosing a low quality example as the alternative to your proposal you’re actually undermining your proposal, rather than setting up against a...

I think the opening post was very interesting right up to painting event based adventures as railroading and map & key based adventures as linear. That isn’t automatically the case. Event based adventures might be railroading but they easily might not. Key and map might be linear - depending on...

Today I learned that DMing for total strangers can really work out. Not every online group of strangers will work but when it does it’s great.

Ha ha yeah I travel from Birmingham to Kent and back. I’m that dedicated and @GuyBoy is that that good a DM. Though we do play face to face monthly for a two day weekend. I don’t think I could do it for a 3 hour session! 😂 I thought you were wowed by the fact that I managed to persuade 4...

What’s the wow for @payn ?