Search results

Agree. I've also done the opposite: Running a PF1 adventure (RotRL) and converting it to PF2. No significant issues.

Haste doesn't let you use Multiattack.

I imagine this is since the 3 big B/X retroclones - Basic Fantasy, LotFP, and Lab. Lord all bolted on a more detailed encumbrance system to the B/X chassis. Nobody played with the "real" encumbrance rules until OSE released them unmodified.

Same. As an example, at a FLGS rpg event near me, the 5e table had 6 players and the indie game table had 2. No one was interested in switching tables.

Not rolling dice is really the worst part of it for me.

Oh absolutely, I won't fight you on that.

There's few places on the internet more insufferable than the r/osr subreddit.

Only option I can think of which fits into this category is Cypher system, or MAYBE the x Without Number books.

Exactly. PF2E does not work that way and will not work for the playstyle you have. You have a razors edge to work with since the balance is so good. No, you don't need system mastery to build encounters. You just need to be able to read a chart and do basic addition, or use a tool like Yet...

I don't think that OSE was expected to blow up like it did. He was originally appealing to die-hard B/X fans who'd both understand and want the different lines. And then the project exploded and 1070% funded, then became even more popular from there.

Very unlikely you'll get a satisfying game doing this with any d20 game, honestly. These are easy to make but I wouldn't recommend doing them at the table. There are charts which you can easily derive values from as long as you know what level you want the monster/item to be. Only takes a...

The box sets are helpful for players because you can hand the spell/character books to your players and hold onto the treasure/monster books for yourself. Its easier to physically pass things like the spell books around the table for the player that needs it rather than everyone competing over...

the image is bigger

What do you mean by 'play fast and loose'?

You don't need to know everything starting out - internalize the most important items and start playing. There's no shame in quickly looking things up as you go. You shouldn't have to learn everything on your own. Your players should be putting in equivalent effort to learn to play rather...

I run it analog all the time, its pretty easy for me.

Understandable - its a specific kind of game that appeals to a specific playstyle, not a system that everyone will love.

The PF2 version is excellent. I can run it with zero modifications. I'd assume the 5e version is comparable quality.

The 3e roundtable was extremely interesting+insightful and the actual one shot is just kinda... slow and lame and bad.

They fit perfectly in when a common B/X party has Elves, Magic Users, and Clerics with magic, and the fighter has a talking sword.