Search results

I'm not going to say you did it wrong, because as you say it was 10 years ago and I have even less to go on since all I have is your post. However... What my group would have done, and we've played many high level 3e/3.5 games, is that we would have scryed out the room. Done auguries...

That is explicitly a check on the entire campaign and setting. "Ultimately, the Dungeon Master is the authority on the campaign and its setting, even if the setting is a published world." And in any case, the DMG also says the DM is not beholden to the rules in the PHB. Edit: They have a...

Where did he say focus fire? All I see are percentages of PCs staying up. If the ogres focus their attacks, there's no way a PC stays up unless in the entire combat the two ogres only score a single hit.

Page 6 "Your DM might set the campaign on one of these worlds or on one that he or she created. Because there is so much diversity among the worlds of D&D, you should check with your DM about any house rules that will affect your play of the game. Ultimately, the Dungeon Master is the authority...

I think you are reading too much into that. It seems to give equal weight to world building and character building from the wording. However, backgrounds are rarely going to conflict with world building, but it can happen. The flipside crafting one to meet the player's story they have in mind...

And fails to involve tactics. Those 2nd level fighters, even with second wind, cannot take two hits without going unconscious, but somehow they have a 50% chance of none of them being knocked out?

Hold on while I calculate how long that will take you based on +1 post per player.

The 5e PHB also told players to check with the DM for changes and the rules gave the DM veto power, but there were still tons of players who felt that if it was in the PHB, they could just pick it. If the DM said no, he was big bad wrong funning them. Putting it in the DMG makes it crystal...

Yeah. I will point out, though, that the Cha 8 guy farting in front of the king can still shift the course of nations. Just maybe not in the direction the PCs want them to go. :P

No. That was never a thing. This has always been about a single +1. For like 12 pages or something. Yes. I do know that a +1 matters little. It still isn't a single +1 like we've been talking about. The expected outcome involves no tactics apparently. Are the ogres all just hitting...

Well, you flubbed the second group. We are trying to look at what +1 str bonus does, yet you gave that group an additional con bonus as well. That needs to go, because it skews the results.

All the stats are good in various spots, but charisma can shift the course of nations.

It wasn't an example meant to be used, as was clear from the context. I was simply showing that percentages don't mean a whole heck of a lot, because that was a 100% increase and the only way you could even begin to make it matter was to cherry pick something ultra weak for the PC to face.

Against a cherry picked CR 1/4 creature. Sure, but I don't see how you can overcome that it still only amounts to one extra hit every multiple combats and that most monsters that aren't cherry picked CR 1/4 are great bags of hit points, so the extra point of damage won't mean much. Unlike you...

Yeaaaah, that ain't actually happening with your math. Your math completely ignores combat abilities, terrain and other things on both sides. Your white room is nifty, but doesn't mean much in actual game play. It doesn't matter. Pick a background that doesn't give a combat feat.

Unless you're suggesting that the PC is never, ever using anything else to attack except for his stat bonus, it will never be more than that. It will always pale in comparison to everything else the PC has to bring to bear. Thanks for proving my point. The PC is probably going to lose whether...

I wondered the same thing, but since I couldn't read the article... 🤷‍♂️

Yep. I went to read it, but I don't do paywalls or account walls.

Yes and no. The +1 won't mean that much with regard to hitting and damage over the long term of the campaign, so it's not all that effective on it's own, but it's also even less effective than that when you add in all the feats, class abilities, spells, etc. that go into a combat. Those are...

I'm not sure if my life was made better or worse for seeing that. Well, today I learned...