Search results

  1. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Mental prison; power creep, typo or working as intended

    I find myself wondering that, if the DM interprets the spell via the flavor text instead of the RAW - does it become a more balanced spell? If you can't abuse it through forced movement, and can escape it with teleportation, maybe it's not too high damage.
  2. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) [HOMEBREW...KIND OF] A Good Dog

    I played a dog PC back in college. He was a very good dog. Ripped a cambion's throat out at the clutch moment. He was green.
  3. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Reliable Talent. What the what?

    And if you do just hand him a loot page he might get bored and stop doing it. Freeing up time for more adventuring.
  4. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) COS - Spoilers! Need plot help.

    The players in my run of CoS were very concerned for Ireena. They screwed up the scene at the shrine, and wound up actually leaving her in the protection of the knights at the keep. Which took some negotiating, especially when they tried to collect her again later. And Strahd went after her...
  5. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) COS - Spoilers! Need plot help.

    Not in your case, no. The players made a choice not to follow a possible branch. But imagine if Gwaihir tells his players about Ireena's kidnapping and they all go "WTF? I thought she was with us? When did this happen?" That's not good for anyone's game. If the players deliberately left...
  6. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) COS - Spoilers! Need plot help.

    Consider asking them, before the next session, whether they meant to do that or just forgot to mention it. Don't punish the players for a mistake.
  7. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Xanathar's and Counterspell

    There wasn't a rule for counterspelling in early D&D because the way to prevent a spellcaster from casting was to hit them with a rock when they tried. Magic Missile was always our go-to - with a casting time of 1, you could frequently break a caster's concentration even if they beat you on...
  8. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Wanting to make a campaign with anime concepts like in anime

    My google-fu is weak, but I remember reading an article about what made anime different - specifically, that certain cultural values were considered primary in Japan, and that they were strongly encoded in the idea of heroism. The one I remember most is the importance of loyalty to one's team...
  9. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Pedantic pet peeves

    It's not supposed to be "could of done that", it's "could've". So it's legitimate, but misspelled. And probably obsolete.
  10. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Fast Initiative ideas?

    I just use index cards with everyone's names on them. I usually note their DEX and Init. bonus too, just in case I need to compare quickly. I also like the monsters take 10 rule, but I usually use 15 for boss monsters.
  11. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Power Level of "Raise Stat to 19" Items

    Personally I think the primary problem comes from the aforementioned +4 CON item (and to a lesser extent +4 DEX). Most of the time giving the wizard a 19 CHA or the thief a 19 INT isn't going to unbalance their character. But lots of people would love a large bonus to HP without paying for it...
  12. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Mercer's Gunslinger Martial Archetype: Good, Bad, or Ugly?

    It probably works best as what it was built for: "I have a player in my Pathfinder game who is using a gunslinger, but we're converting to D&D 5e. Let me write something up."
  13. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Mystic playtest...ugg this class is all over the place

    My first game of 5e - my wife played a cleric with Sacred Flame. I'm not sure it EVER worked. The monsters just had freakish luck when she used that cantrip. That's the risk you take when you use save to neg. spells for damage.
  14. Savage Wombat

    Xanathar's War Mage is Gandalf, Dr Strange, and Elric

    I am now imagining a warlock who gets spells from generous internet supporters.
  15. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Homebrew Cleric Domain: LGBT Domain (Positive & Respectful)

    I'd just go with God of Rainbows and extrapolate from there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iris_(mythology)
  16. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Are solo monsters weaker in 5e?

    I seem to remember in 4e that a given solo was intended to be equivalent to a certain number of normal monsters of the same CR - I think it was 5? Anyway - does a 4e solo monster have more HP, as a rule, than the group of monsters he replaces added together? I'm curious what the building...
  17. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Help me populate the nobles of an imperial capital in decline

    I think you should have that guy from the commercial with the tiny giraffe.
  18. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) Failing saves is...ok?

    So you're saying a "failed" saving throw should always advance the story in some fashion?
  19. Savage Wombat

    D&D 5E (2014) [poll] Sorcerer Satisfaction Survey

    The new sorcerer themes are an improvement, but they don't quite go far enough. And the balance issues vis-à-vis the wizard remain difficult to resolve. I like the ENWorld thread with suggestions, though.
Top