Search results

This might help:

The issue there is not Arcane Burst, but that the Archmage can cast it 4x per round. I think WotC made some bad choices with spellcasting creatures in 5e24. That is not how I would do it.

I am going to second @Micah Sweet on this one. I, as DM, enjoy world building first, time with my friends 2nd, and engaging adventures/campaigns 3rd. They are interrelated and I value all of them, but that is my personal order of enjoyment. So I want my world to make sense as a world first and...

Added to my cart! First DMsGuild product Months! PS Kaz the Minotaur and The Legend of Huma are my two favorite books outside the original trilogy (maybe even better than those in some areas).

I don't remember if @Micah Sweet likes Dragonlance, but this is how I believe they want to see the DMs Guild used: quality 3PP content in classic TSR / WotC settings!

Do you not see that is what you are suggesting? At least that is how I see it. Unless you have a draft you can share I will not believe it otherwise.

Demanding maybe, but wanting the game to be designed how you want to play it is hardly odd.

By them not being levels you make them 2nd class citizens and that never goes well I guess I simply don't believe you yet. Until I see a draft of actual rules / guidelines I simple don't see what you are trying to do that can't be done equally as well or better with levels. Keep in mind that...

Yep, It is not that it can't be done, but the bold part is going to be really hard. Heck, when I suggest novice levels should be actual levels, @EzekielRaiden says no, no they shouldn't be actual levels, they should be incremental advancement. As if that is a better solution than starting at...

Sorry, I need to clarify that I was not talking about PF2e. I was talking about my 5e14 homebrew game

I have been thinking about using a modified 3 action system where you get your base movement for free (and like 5e can use it before, in-between, or after your actions). You then spend your action points on actions like PF2, but you also need to spend an action point on reactions. So no action...

Well this person was speaking from a DM perspective and being able to threaten their PCs

Interesting, I have had another gamer tell me that boss fights were one of the best pasts of PF2e. IDK, I haven't played, but that was on of the drivers for potentially pushing me to play PF2e.

"I believe it's called 'jogging' or 'yogging.' it might be a soft j. I'm not sure but apparently you just run for an extended period of time. It is supposed to be wild" - Ron Burgundy "Anchorman" Sorry, this is the first thing that popped into my head.

Relative size / impact of companies too. What WotC does has a bigger impact in the TTRPG space so you get a bigger response and likely a wider range / larger number of people who care.

Interesting, I guess you haven't been to the pacific northwest (or the northeast, or southeast, or midwest) of America

There is a trend for every odd edition to be the big success, so maybe 7e will bring you back!

Although a 6e could be even more popular and draw even more 3PP support and potentially kill other systems and increase the dominance of Hasbro/WotC. You need to be careful what you wish for!;)

I like all the boxed set action!