Search results

  1. billd91

    D&D General Weapon Mastery - Yea or Nay?

    I think they're a bit "one note"-ish in the sense that the one note each weapon plays is repeatedly spammed. If anybody thought the trip attacks people made with the spiked chain back in 3e was tedious, don't let anyone pick topple. Granted, I think the 5e.2024 implementation is at least a...
  2. billd91

    New Edition of Mutants & Masterminds Coming Soon, Playtest Launches at End of Month

    I expect they'll kickstarter it. And no, they're not grifters. Nobody is being swindled or conned to help them with legal fees.
  3. billd91

    D&D General Did 5e 2024 Not meet the economic goals set, and if not, why not?

    Are you serious? With all the jabs at wokeness with various publishers and products in the RPG industry? Of course, this is going to be something you might want to consider, particularly with highly critical clickbait or claims of "failure" by people on the internet. It might be ridiculous we...
  4. billd91

    Old shows that you enjoy?

    Tailspin was pretty inspired. Shere Khan as a corporate. The behavior and mannerisms of Don Karnage and his air pirates.
  5. billd91

    Stop Looking At Your Character Sheet

    Hey now, the rat-bastard keeper in me is saying that should be a GROUP Luck check - and that means you use the lowest Luck score in the group.
  6. billd91

    Old shows that you enjoy?

    I have The Man From U.N.C.L.E on DVD as well as Star Trek: The Animated Series, WKRP in Cincinnati, The Muppet Show, and Jonny Quest.
  7. billd91

    Stop Looking At Your Character Sheet

    The wording here was particular interesting because referring to the food as a "trick" evokes references to 1e DMG Appendix H where a number of tricks were described. Basically, a trick is akin to a trap in that it's a hidden property of something, just not necessarily something set up as a...
  8. billd91

    Sinners (2025)

    That wouldn't preclude him from being in Ireland during years of plantations, dispossessions, and uprisings before traveling to America. Remmick's statements may erroneously conflate religious conversion with dispossessions a bit since Ireland generally wasn't converted to Christianity by...
  9. billd91

    Stop Looking At Your Character Sheet

    Wow. You even see things like that come up in party games like Codenames. You'll give a clue that, you think, links pretty much exclusively to a couple of cards on display and someone will have some weird association and screw it up. It's almost enough to think some people just don't speak the...
  10. billd91

    Green Ronin Crowdfunding Legal Defense Fund In Fight Against Diamond Distrubutors

    Good luck to Green Ronin. I tossed in a few bucks to help them out even if I'm not really buying much from them these days.
  11. billd91

    D&D 5E (2024) Weird Potion House Rule Idea

    It has been my experience that potions tend to be forgotten, same with inspiration. When a DM friend of mine gave out inspiration as poker chips, we used it fairly regularly. Without the physical token reminder, it is often forgotten. I think I’ll start using chips for inspiration in my game...
  12. billd91

    Sinners (2025)

    I think it also gives us closure that
  13. billd91

    What do you do when a Player dies?

    I've lost a few friends that I gamed with, none were active at any table I played in at the time they died, but I had played games with them for years before. The first was Dave, a friend I met in college. He was an occasional RPGer but mostly played board games and war games. He was a wiz at...
  14. billd91

    Sinners (2025)

    You may not really see much of the shark other than shadows and fins, but he is demonstrably present right from the first scene.
  15. billd91

    What makes a successful horror game?

    Whether or not Sanity matters only if you lose a large amount in a short time depends on whether or not you are playing a one-shot or a campaign. In a one-shot scenario, yeah, small Sanity losses aren't a very big deal. But if you plan on playing more than one or two scenarios with that...
  16. billd91

    D&D 5E (2014) Can you retry a failed skill check? How long?

    The idea of just saying "Yes, you succeed" without a roll is to save the rolls for when you really want it - such as when there's an actual consequence of failing other than having to try again to get it right or when the pressure is really on (like in a crisis such as combat). This is part of...
  17. billd91

    D&D 5E (2014) Can you retry a failed skill check? How long?

    If it's within their ability (DC isn't too high to achieve) and there's no cost of failure (plenty of time, no wandering monsters, etc), then yeah, they should succeed without rolling. It's not and shouldn't be a challenge.
  18. billd91

    D&D 5E (2014) Can you retry a failed skill check? How long?

    I don't really get the idea that trying again removes any real challenge. It just changes the terms a bit. Using your example above, if you can't pick the lock you have to try something else - like breaking down the door. Is that really a different challenge in any significant way? In both...
  19. billd91

    Pineapple Express: Someone Is Wrong on the Internet?

    If I had a dog that looked like that, I’d have to name it Blueberry Muffin. I mean, you can see it, right?
  20. billd91

    D&D General How Do I Help Mentor a GM Making Rookie Mistakes?

    I think maybe you'd be best off with a one on one chat and say that you have some questions that you'd like clarified without trying to call any of them "rookie mistakes". Rookies are expected to make mistakes - it's one way they learn. You can even talk about how these house rules should be...
Top