Search results

The touching on other settings is in the Vecna book, not this one.

I'm guessing you haven't been in the LEGO market recently

As I mentioned elsewhere, that is basically what we do (and like) as well. However, I am all for the game having options for more or less rules for those who want them. Now, my next question: Do you, or would you, except the same approach for combat that you just described for a social encounter?

I feel like I am going in circles a bit so I may have miss-spoke somewhere, but I don't think I ever advocated a social combat system that reward talkers on top of the social combat system mechanics.

So again, it return to the fact that this is a "D&D General" thread. I don't think it is about specific edition rules, but what could be and what you would like to see. So, I guess my question to you is - what would you like to see. As I have already noted I would like to a range of rules on...

Of course that is precisely what you are doing by not having some degree of social combat rules. As a reminder, this is my original post on this thread (post #53): "Ideally I would like to see three options implemented, even if we (my group) would only use option 3: Social combat rules: Rules...

Why don't you take the same approach to social situations?

Well this is tagged "D&D General" so I wasn't constraining myself to a specific interpretation of D&D To be clear, are you advocating that player narration can affect social encounter rolls and out comes for the characters? Are you also suggesting this doesn't mess up the mechanical balance of...

You can play that why. However, if you allow narration to affect social rolls, why not allow it to affect combat rolls. We have, in fact, played where our narration matters. The typical result of good combat narration is advantage on an attack or damage (roll damage twice and take higher). I...

What cartoon comic collection are you referring too? Iink?

Also, don't people narrate and roleplay in combat? I know we do!

I am curious: what do you think my interpretation is? Because I basically agree with this statement below, and I don't think anything the OP contradicts that.

@dave2008 has some good high CR monsters on this forum: 5e Updates - Monstrous Compendium He has a Monster by CR list to, but I am not sure it is 100% up to date: Monsters by CR There are 137+ monsters CR 15 or greater on that thread. PS - I just checked and not all of the monsters have made...

I disagree. I've read the OP 3 times and I don't feel JW suggested it was removed immediately. I don't necessarily think your interpretation is wrong, I just don't think it is any more correct than mine.

That doesn't exactly contradict what JW said in the OP, it is just a bit more detail really

Ideally I would like to see three options implemented, even if we (my group) would only use option 3: Social combat rules: Rules and guidelines for social interaction nearly as detailed as combat/movement/position rules Social Interaction guidelines: Something similar to a skill challenge...

I am pretty sure the artist of this one is Jeff Easley

Typhoon Dragon 4-2=2 Volcanic Dragon 21+1=22 One post to soon!

Very interesting - thank you for sharing!

There are no rules for necro-posting. I think the mode as just letting you know the thread was 18 years old