Search results

  1. Committed Hero

    Math on low-roll wins vs blackjack...

    There can be systems where a low-skilled person's proportion of critical successes exceed those of a more skilled character. If I need a natural 20 to hit that dragon, all of my hits are going to be crits!
  2. Committed Hero

    When to set a "historical" supers game? (read OP before answering poll)

    Way back in Pyramid Online, Ken Hite wrote five supers seeds set in historical periods: Marvel Heroes in Imperial Rome DC Heroes in Renaissance Italy 99 Muslim heroes - one for each name of Allah - in the Crusades Civil War Indian Wars. Each one sounded great. "The alien craft fell to earth...
  3. Committed Hero

    Math on low-roll wins vs blackjack...

    In a low roll wins scenario, there will be more instances where the more skilled individual succeeds while the less skilled one fails altogether. But in the cases where the latter succeeds, it negates the former's higher skill level.
  4. Committed Hero

    RPG Systems Family Tree?

    I would say that Ars Magica is a progenitor of the d20 system as well. Jonathan Tweet worked on both, and the universal resolution is pretty similar.
  5. Committed Hero

    Monster Catalogue vs. Monster Creation Rules (vs. Why Not Both?)

    The more a game is an exercise in tactical combat, the more it will benefit from a catalog of monsters. This is both for the novelty of encountering different challenges, and the likely necessity of antagonists at different power levels. Gumshoe occupies an interesting middle ground - in most...
  6. Committed Hero

    It's been so long since the last GURPS edition, that the present day is now in the "future" tech level

    "Realism" in a system is a perfectly acceptable goal, and GURPS has indeed striven to achieve it. But it clashes with principles of PC generation for me. I understand why Nuclear Physics should cost more than Unarmed Combat in reality; chances are, however, a higher rating in the latter will...
  7. Committed Hero

    NPC Deception/Persuasion and player agency

    "You think he's being sincere" has enough room for a duplicitous NPC to be lying.
  8. Committed Hero

    Do you prefer your adventures to be episodic or contiguous?

    Crom! My games tend to be contiguous, but there is always room for discrete adventures.
  9. Committed Hero

    What TTRPG Is Perfect and Complete In One Volume?

    Night's Black Agents. Arguably the only thing the author has tinkered with since its release is the chase rules. Other GM-forward releases have only expounded on the core material.
  10. Committed Hero

    Payn's Ponderings~ Campaign settings and you?

    A giant beehive balanced on top of a mountain, and the PCs and major NPCs swinging a lot of ten foot poles around near the summit.
  11. Committed Hero

    House rules to eliminate "dead rounds" + Shaken from Savage Worlds (and ... it kind of ends up like hit points)

    Because you play more than just high fantasy :) SW is a pretty good universal system.
  12. Committed Hero

    The 1966 Hobbit cartoon

    Still better than The Battle of Five Armies.
  13. Committed Hero

    Brain Teaser- Decide a Case Better than a Judge!

    After all, the driver can choose to put a flag sticker on his car, which expresses what he's trying to say.
  14. Committed Hero

    Brain Teaser- Decide a Case Better than a Judge!

    Some states require car owner signatures to propose new designs; mine requires a vote of the state leg.
  15. Committed Hero

    D&D General Just sweeping dirty dishes under the rug: D&D, Sexism, and the '70s

    I would also add that the Avalanche Press covers are on the younger end of the 25-year dividing line.
  16. Committed Hero

    D&D General Just sweeping dirty dishes under the rug: D&D, Sexism, and the '70s

    That's what makes this discussion a bit more interesting. There was a definite line over which AD&D misogyny could cross; and did - in the first version of Palace of the Silver Princess. And while it is gratifying that the line has moved in a positive direction, I understand those who would...
  17. Committed Hero

    Aging and Gaming

    For me, the reality is that my time is limited and the pool of players I have to try new stuff is small. I was lucky to play/run 6 different games this year, and they were all games I had played before.
  18. Committed Hero

    Aging and Gaming

    I'm in your age bracket. I want to play, not learn new stuff.
  19. Committed Hero

    How to Tell a Player, "No"?

    If the player is a novice gamer, do they know that this is an unusual request for a PC? If they are a veteran player, do they have a sourcebook they are asking to be used? I think you can offer something similar to the concept, but you are in your rights to say no if they keep pushing back...
  20. Committed Hero

    Your Most Useful and Most Used RPG Products

    That's a great idea. Also available for free: https://dwarfstar.brainiac.com/ds_barbarianprince.html
Top