Sure. Businesses and fan bases are going to market. I think the real value is in the nominated list. You get to see games you might not know exist otherwise. The winner is always going to be subjective.
I think I might ask each player directly how it's going to impact them, and we need to jointly agree that it will be a negative effect, not twisted into something that doesn't make sense.
But doesn't each condition only affect one stat? You wouldn't have 2 stacked banes on CON, for example, you'd have a bane on CON and say AGL if I read things correctly? And yes, I know it's on associated skills as well.
The other mechanic I am really liking is the Healing skill. It doesn't simply give you immediate HP on success but rather augments healing done while doing a normal stretch rest. So simple, but you wonder why no one has thought of it before.