Search results

  1. J

    Pie Wedge Initiative?

    In Fantasy Infinity, I'm using something like this. In my system, there is a (fairly abstract, compared to 3rd and 4th generation D&D) "battle board" everyone is assumed to be sitting around anyway, though the playtest version is actually a magnetic whiteboard that tends to be propped up next to...
  2. J

    D&D 5E (2014) Signs & Portents (that we can read into) about the ETA of 5E

    Based on my own inquiries, twelve for a boxed set is as crazy as two, just in the opposite direction. (My own inquiries concerned a boxed set in a generally Eurogamish style, though it was for an RPG, not a boardgame.) Of course, I was talking about significantly shorter print runs than WotC...
  3. J

    Beyond Old and New School - "The Secret That Was Lost"

    This looks fun, even though it seems only tangentially related to the thread. (As an aside, it seems to me this is a more useful exercise if you're planning on running 13th Age or The Pool than any flavour of D&D, though it might be somewhat useful for Next or for 1E with secondary skills.) In...
  4. J

    A solution to the "core books sell" problem?

    Even if they were to implement the basic suggestion of this thread - i.e. do several RPG lines instead of just D&D, using some of the resources that would otherwise go to D&D splatbooks - this is the single thing they are LEAST likely to do. They already have a medieval fantasy RPG that uses the...
  5. J

    What's OLD is NEW

    Most if not all of the O.L.D. artwork was originally done for the War of the Burning Sky online game (that seems to have become vaporware). And I think some of the N.E.W. work has its origins in that space combat game Morrus did - I've definitely seen some of it before, anyway. Everything in the...
  6. J

    Proposed Character Sheet

    Surprised that you got such negative reactions to that earlier draft, HR. I for one would be interested in seeing it. Maybe those folks were conflating "useful as a handout in its own right" (which I readily concede the spell list part is) with "appropriate for a character sheet"? Or, my...
  7. J

    Proposed Character Sheet

    I think a character sheet should never, never, assume that every campaign uses all and only the default skills, spells, classes or feats. The spell list might be a useful handout in its own right but I don't think it's appropriate for a character sheet specifically. I'd rather have space to fill...
  8. J

    D&D 5E (2014) Signs & Portents (that we can read into) about the ETA of 5E

    I'm not guessing here. My previous post is based on actual quotes from Chinese printers, and for much smaller volumes than WotC would be getting.
  9. J

    D&D 5E (2014) Signs & Portents (that we can read into) about the ETA of 5E

    Well, of course they publish in the US, for certain senses of "publish". I assume you mean "print". And I'm pretty sure they do that in China, or some products in the US (or Canada) and some in China. But I can only assume the estimates for printing time I've seen in this thread ARE for...
  10. J

    OotS #228 - Go

    The latest Order of the Stick is up. Basically more back-and-forth momentum shifting in the fight with Tarquin and friends.
  11. J

    Words, Phrases, and Misspellings We Hate

    "Different to" is British, and not universally accepted even there. "Different than" is US. Both, especially the latter, are generally considered fairly informal, with "different from" preferred in formal contexts on both sides of the Atlantic.
  12. J

    Words, Phrases, and Misspellings We Hate

    I used to sig ones I noticed a lot on other posts here. Some that I remember doing that with or at least being tempted to: Saying "loose" (the opposite of "tight") when you obviously mean "lose" (the opposite of "win" or "gain"). Just one of the many editing problems that made me stop trying to...
  13. J

    Of the WotC Forums and the OTT

    I'm not denying that it's the official story. I'm saying the official story probably isn't accurate, or at the very least, that to the extent that it is, that reflects poorly on WotC.
  14. J

    Of the WotC Forums and the OTT

    I've heard some plausible scenarios where the need to change could be out of their hands, but none where it sneaks up on them this suddenly.
  15. J

    The FINAL FANTASY INFINITY project - Preview Thread

    I have posted a detailed example of character creation, including a legible Destiny Wheel, over at RPGGeek (scroll down, or follow the link at the end of the first post). Check it out!
  16. J

    That Penny Arcade Controversy

    Cadence, I'm not the original target of the above post, but for my own part my responses would be as follows: A: Unproblematic. B: Nothing you have specifically described them as doing strikes me as the least bit unethical, or indeed, as differing in any significant respect from what you...
  17. J

    I'm looking for a "island's in the sky" sort of setting. Anyone know where I can find one?

    I'll be doing a Mobius-strip shaped world with some of these elements for Fantasy Infinity. That may or may not be close enough to what you're looking for. It might not be out soon enough for your liking, though - we're still (counts on fingers...) nine, really closer to ten, months from my...
  18. J

    Melee and Ranged Combat Rules Changes in SAGA Edition

    When I wanted more of a Knights of the Old Republic feel (melee is common, and at least as good as ranged a lot of the time) rather than the default SWSE feel (based on the movies, where melee is rare), I simply added a die of damage to each melee weapon, as well as adding a few additional melee...
  19. J

    The FINAL FANTASY INFINITY project - Preview Thread

    Default Setting (and a general update) I've been very busy this past week educating myself on the business side of starting a company. For example, I've secured the name "Philosoraptor Game Studio" as well as learning a LOT about marketing, taxes, and other business necessities and...
  20. J

    OotS 913

    Really? A lot of Rich's plot twists have taken me completely by surprise but this was not one of them, largely for the reason Tarquin gives in the third-from-last panel. The only question was whether Tarquin was going to do the honours himself or merely stand by while someone else did.
Top