Search results

From now until January 31st, you can pick up Precis Intermedia's Iron & Gold Expanded RPG for 20% off! Click on the link to apply the discount. Please note my use of affiliate links in this post.

Just a reminder that this huge bundle will expire at the end of the month!

This is somewhat tangential (and specific) to what you were saying, but things like that remind me of 3.5's Magic Item Compendium. For the most part, I loved that book. Yes, it had several pages of errata fixing specific instances of its central conceit (i.e. the prices of magic items) but its...

I just finished The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook, which is book three of the Dungeon Crawler Carl series. I enjoyed this one, but felt like the bloom was beginning to come off of the rose somewhat. The author, Matt Dinniman, seemed to get a little too caught up in explaining the...

For the next two weeks, you can get Radmad RPGs' Blood Neon and Blood Neon - Atomic Shock each 50% off! Go check them out before the prices go back up! Please note my use of affiliate links in this post.

Which is notable when you recall the fact that much of said missing content was held back deliberately in order to help boost sales of subsequent books.

I just finished reading Lee Child's 1998 novel Die Trying, the second book in his Jack Reacher series. I mentioned a few months ago that I'd picked up a Jack Reacher book out of a Little Free Library in my neighbor's front yard, and decided to move this one up in my queue (mostly so that I...

I think that there's an inherent design strength to the binder's having thematic packages of abilities (i.e. vestiges) that can be swapped out on a regular basis. Leaving aside the versatility involved, this makes it easier to note which vestiges have design problems, and so can be dealt with in...

This grossly mischaracterizes this edition's attitude, which is entirely themed around "you don't need a rule for this, just have your character do it," while telling GMs that they should bend over backwards to accomodate their players, on top of making it even harder for PCs to fail at things...

Sure, I also recommended having more sections of advice for GMs; I think that's a good thing. I'm just against trying to hard-code rules around things that GMs can't do, is all. That way lies little benefit and much potential for problems. The idea that "evolution = improvement" isn't...

There's a vast world of difference between "it really does happen" and "it's a major problem that's been crying out for a solution for a long time now." That's worth remembering, because you seem to be trying to suggest that the former is the latter, despite the latter not being a thing at all...

TTRPGs aren't boardgames, and shouldn't be judged by their standards, since they necessarily limit what anyone playing them can do. Imposing those same sorts of limits are too high a price to make TTRPGs "safe" from bad GMs. (Besides, we already have boardgames; if you're that worried about a...

Sure, but the way to solve the problems of mismatches of expectations between players and GMs is by an honest dialogue. At best, you can write advice about that into the sections on GMing, but even then that's just that: advice. At the proverbial end of the day, the player(s) and GM need to talk...

Haha, nope! Spell selection isn't anywhere near that much, and it's hard to countenance any suggestion that it is. My point is that your point about how GMs will apparently screw with a PC's sheet willy-nilly comes across as difficult to take seriously. Particularly since you seem to be...

From now through the end of the month, dicegeeks has marked all of their "Book of Random Tables" products down to $2.99 each! Go check them out before the sale ends! Please note my use of affiliate links in this post.

I think that this is true for a lot of game engines, be they computer or tabletop, at least if they're "sufficiently" (whatever that means) complex. For instance, in 3.5E we saw a sweeping change, late in the life of the game, where a large swath of monsters that had polymorph (or a similar...

I don't have a source on this, but my understanding is that the various restrictions on spellcasters in AD&D 1E and 2E were an example of this. That is, things like wizards needing to spend "round segments" casting their spells; automatically losing them if anything broke their concentration...

It's funny that you mention that. I was at Gen Con in 2007 when 4E was announced, and in the seminar where they said that there wouldn't be Vancian casting, the entire room burst into applause. I remember being stunned by that.

To reiterate what Riggs said in his seminar, "one thing that stayed popular from the get-go was the idea of implementing "cooldown" periods for powers. This eventually became the AED part of the AEDU suites of abilities."

You're not wrong about that. None other than Ben Riggs has told us that WoW was the impetus for 4E's creation, and that designers were told to try and build a game that would appeal to its audience.