Search results

So? Just the more reason for WotC to improve upon them. Edit: I'm still looking forward to your pricing on the examples I mentioned earlier.

No, you get told you are badwrongfun when you don't want other people to have a proper rules supported option of including magic item pricing, while you could just decide not to use it. Also, we are not talking item market per se, but pricing for items relatively to each other. Not for what...

But we're not talking about TSR editions, for f***s sake! We're talking about WotC D&D. How many editions has WotC created for D&D? 3. And for two out of those, magic item pricing was an integrated part. Now it is not. People missing that points that out. They then get told what they want is...

Theses are the best that I know of: Blackball’s Treasure (the one I mostly base my own attempts on) https://www.dmsguild.com/product/272584/Expanded-Special-Feature-Manual Also, The Angry DM has a nice attempt as well (though he oes factor ririty into it), but the site is down for me right...

Right. Again, thanks for your go at this. But this discussion is about 5e, so I don't think your examples are that relevant. I'd be very interested in your take on those items I suggested in 5e, though.

Thanks. The reason why I asked about the armors is because due to bounded accuracy, the plusses that don't break the max AC for light, medium and heavy armor should have little impact on price. So magic plate should be the heavy armor you base pricing on. What I see is that you totally ditch...

And where is that? I (and I think others are too) am very interested in some examples. Especially since I find it very hard. How about some flight items comparatively, a +2 chain shirt, and a +1 scale mail vs a +1 plate. Throw in a amulet of health to get us started. Thanks.

In the real world,sure. Everybody knows the rarity system in 5e is bonkers, with items giving flight once cost ten times an item granting continuous flight and so on. What people disagree on is whether that's a problem or not. The only (sane, thus the title of this thread) way to price magic...

There was use for gold back then. It was xp. But you're basing this on rarity, when it should be based on utility. It's sort the whole premise of the thread (though I admit the endless bickering might have made me mix this thread up with older similar threads).

Over 150 fears :eek: ;)

If you are not joking, do a little googling around 😉

You've got Fireball as a necromancy spell.

So, @CapnZapp , are you giving up on pf2? And if so, return to 5e?

Barely an inconvenience.

The original Freeport Trilogy is a classic snakemen adventure, and highly regarded. I've heard good things about Fortress of the Yuan-Ti (3.5). I enjoyed The Tyrant's Oath from Dungeon 178 (4e).

There was also the Mageknight Apocalypse Dragon Image for scale

Now, I didn't back so I haven't read it, but there's a lengthy discussion on rpg.net, that kinda makes me wish I had. I will be following this with growing interest. I've always wanted to try out SW, and am planning RotR for the next campaign or the one after.

Good. Catches a Str god's flavour nicely. Didn't know you'd be doing avatars? You went back to legendary resistance, or it this a wip?

That Phane is really cool. Like it! Only thing, keep it to just an Int save versus Stasis Touch. Too rarely are they used and it'll put fear into clerics, paladins and everyone else buffing Wis saves 😈