Search results

I don't particularly like the way Shackled City was handled. I think a game should only be entered into one product type contest (ie. Best Adventure or Best setting), not both. By the logic used last year all campaign setting should be eligible for best adventure and all adventures should be...

AD&D 2nd Ed PHB. It is what got me into gaming and I can still remember the big smile I had for a full week after getting it.

The only one I can think of this year that I didn't like was Metamorphosis Alpha: 4th Edition. It wasn't what I thought it was and on top of that it was disaster in organization and layout. Of course I can admit that some of this was personal preference and others might think differently. Still...

Old World of Darkness. The New World of Darkness just does not give me that cool vibe I got from OWoD. The rules in NWoD are better though. I don't fit into just one. I would say that I'm mix of narrativist and simulationist. More than likely, whether or not I'm a judge. They creative and...

As much as possible. Since there will be a couple hundred or more books, there is just no way to playtest all of them while reading them as well. Even if you had 8 hours every day, I doubt you could playtest them all. Some of the enteries i may have played already, so that might help. Well, it...

I think as long as they(the rules) were reviewed on a yearly basis, it could work. It think that some very general points to judge games on would be a good idea. (Note: granted each judge would put their own significance to each point, but at least they would all be covering the same points?)...

I do post here some, but I primarily post @ The RPG Site. I think there is some "meaningful" conversation over on The RPG Site. I fully admit that d20 is not my primary system, though I do tend play it a d20 campaign every year. As far as people having to register here, personally if it is to...

The deliberations have to be held someplace, does it really matter that it is done here? Again, Rasyr this thread is for asking the ENnies judge Nominees questions that help people decide who they want to vote for, not for showing how much you dislike them.

I started in 1989 so 17 years, soon to be 18. I think it does somewhat affect my perspective because I have seen and played so many different games that a product has to be truely outstanding (IMO, of course) if I get excited about it. I have been homebrewing fromt the begining. I rarely use...

normally none, but if they (knowingly)do something really stupid, I'm not going to bail them out.

Any of the ones Mike Mearls wrote are good.

I just started a similar thread on The RPG Site. Nominees, please stop by and check it out. Just keep in mind that things are a little more rowdy over there than you may be used to here. :) thanks. The RPG Site

Well, I think it is more of a lack of other sites not taking part more than anyone here discouraging it. I post over on The RPG Site more than anywhere. If someone started a similar post there or any other gaming forum I'd be happy to answer the questions. but this thread is for asking the...

Iridium System is OGL.

I will most likely buy the corebooks, but the supplements depend on how much I like 4e.

When I'm looking for players I will normally put a little blurb in my Sig that I'm looking. As has been mentioned, it is very important to let people know where you are located as well.

Not at all. I judge a game based on absolute quality. When doing a review, I comment on the quality of the product and leave it to the reader to decide if it is a good value for their gaming purposes. It just seems to work better that way, given that people have differing opinions of what makes...

the rpg site Board Game Geek RPG.net

Well, its been a while since I have picked up any WotC stuff, but it looks like there will be @ least three sold to me this year.

I cut my RPG teeth on 2ed and I still perfer it to any of the other editions. It has its problems, but its not like 1st or 3rd don't.