Search results

  1. scruffygrognard

    What would WotC need to do to win back the disenchanted?

    It wasn't a claim... I was offering my perception of WotC's actions in both the marketing and creation of 4th edition. To my eyes there were enough significant changes made to the game, whether they be in style, implied background, rule mechanics, etc, that I could only conclude that they were...
  2. scruffygrognard

    What would WotC need to do to win back the disenchanted?

    Other than a few posters getting a little over-heated, I haven't seen a lot of rage in this thread... just insights into what drove people away from WotC and what could bring them back. As someone who has played every version of D&D and AD&D that has been released over the past 30 years, I'm...
  3. scruffygrognard

    What would WotC need to do to win back the disenchanted?

    I have no expectation that it will be soon and/or reactionary ... but the point of this thread is to see what would make lost customers return to WotC. For me 4th edition would need to go away and 5th edition would need to reacquaint itself with many classic D&Dism to bring me back. Until...
  4. scruffygrognard

    What would WotC need to do to win back the disenchanted?

    I should have stated that a bit more clearly. -------------------------------------- 2] WotC should ditch 4th edition and its design goals to create a 5th edition that strongly resembles the D&D that I've played for the past 30 years. There is room for innovation and streamlining (I'm thinking...
  5. scruffygrognard

    What would WotC need to do to win back the disenchanted?

    If WotC were smart, the next iteration of D&D would be modular enough to allow for rules-lite D&D. The core books would present classic races, monsters and classes, and the fundamental rules needed to run the game, as was the case with 3.X. The fundamental rules could easily be pared down...
  6. scruffygrognard

    What would WotC need to do to win back the disenchanted?

    To come back into the fold, I'd need WotC to: 1] Re-release pdfs, particularly of older edition materials. 2] Ditch 4th edition and go back to D&D's roots to create a game that strongly resembles the D&D that I've played for the past 30 years. There is room for innovation and streamlining (I'm...
  7. scruffygrognard

    T1-4 Temple of Elemental Evil 3.5 Conversion Complete!

    Could you also send it to me? csperkins1970@gmail.com Thanks in advance!
  8. scruffygrognard

    Playing a Diviner

    If you're going that route, be sure to be a cloistered cleric from Unearthed Arcana. The extra skill points, added domain & spells, and lore ability are worth the loss of a few hit points, points of BAB and weapon/armor proficiencies. Besides, as a cleric/wizard, you're strength lies in your...
  9. scruffygrognard

    Adventure Group Names

    We went the stupid route and chose "The Electric Youth" as our group name.
  10. scruffygrognard

    GMing for the first time in 20+ years tomorrow!

    Good luck and have fun! Savage Worlds is a fun, flexible system that you all should pick up on pretty quickly. I've only played it a few times so I can't offer any deep insights into the rule set. Ad for GMing, keep it fast and loose and don't get too bogged down by the rules. Try to enjoy...
  11. scruffygrognard

    D&D 3.x [3.5] CHALLENGE: Best way to hide/protect an item

    Animate it. Animate Object turns an object into a construct. You can't use Locate Object to locate a construct... Same goes for casting Polymorph Any Object on an object.
  12. scruffygrognard

    If Great Figures in History were Gamers

    I must protest! Shakespeare would clearly be a bard. He is, after all, The Bard of Avon. ;)
  13. scruffygrognard

    War of the Ring

    I just got the Collector's Edition and it is a piece of art... it's beautifully done. I got it exactly for the reasons you listed but am now afraid to use it. :eek: Because of that, I'll eventually get the regular version and enshrine the Collector's Edition. I can't comment on the rules at...
  14. scruffygrognard

    Mearls is the new manager of D&D

    Congratulations and, hopefully, you are able to inspire those who dropped D&D with the release of 4th edition to return to the fold. I, for one, would love to see D&D return to its roots and get "back to basics"... but with new, innovative and flexible rules that make the game fun for DMs and...
  15. scruffygrognard

    Slumbering Tsar Subscription Service is live!

    I'm in and can't wait to see how this rolls out.
  16. scruffygrognard

    Announcing a Vintage/Old School RPG Gaming Convention in Connecticut!!

    It falls on my 40th birthday, plus I dig Old School gaming... so it must be full of awesomeness. ;)
  17. scruffygrognard

    Any news from Gygax Games yet?

    With all due respect to Gail Gygax, I think she is missing her best opportunity to release EGG's works. The OSR seems to picking up steam and there are plenty of people, like me, with a renewed interest in old school products... especially those penned by Gary Gygax himself. I realize that...
  18. scruffygrognard

    Where do you see (or want) 5.0 to go?

    My perspective on this is this is that, after playing 3rd edition for 10 years and playing 4th edition a number of times until I tired of it, I think that looking back at earlier editions of D&D might be what's best for the game. I'm not saying that Basic and AD&D are perfect, but they are have...
  19. scruffygrognard

    Where do you see (or want) 5.0 to go?

    Move away from the rules-heavy model of 3.5 and 4th edition to create a fun, fast and rules lite d20 game. Start with the basics (including classic races and classes, as well as Vancian magic) and build an awesome game around the simple core rules.
  20. scruffygrognard

    Pathfinder 1E You're the CEO of PAIZO. Now What?

    Exactly what I was thinking.
Top