Search results

Not really :) . I still think I am right, you still think you are right so people will choose whatever rule they feel is right. I am not misinforming, I am just expressing my point of view on the rules. Unless we get an official ruling from WotC that is what they are opinions. :D

Because all those feats you mention above state that you should "see the Dungeon Master´s Guide for prerequisites and other information on ITEM", yet Scribe Scroll, Craft Wands and Brew Potion do not. Why it is not clearly stated? I would think that the text "You can create a scroll of any...

Then why the different wording in the feats description? While not say that you can create any scroll, potion or wands whose prerequisites you meet? The different wording means that they have different rules. And a particular rule can trump a general rule, as it usually is more limited in a...

That is where you are mistaken. Re-read the item creation feats: Scribe Scroll, Brew Potion and Craft Wands say that you can create the appropiate item of any spell you know (subject to the limits of the feat). Craft Magic Arms and Armor, Craft Rod, Craft Staff and Craft Woundrous Items say...

Then why does the Scribe Scroll feat specifically state that you must known the spell to be scribed? (The same goes with the Brew potion or Craft Wand feats), while the other item creation feats clearly state that you can create an item (ring, staff, woundrous items) whose prerequisites you...