Search results

No way Forge of Fury (3e) could be done in four hours. I just ran my group through Sunless Citadel, and it took four sessions. (Forge of Fury is next on our agenda.) You might want to check out the various Living Greyhawk modules for 3e. Most were written to be played in 4 hours. I think RPG...

One of my players thinks that (a) shields should qualify as 'light' improvised weapons, and (b) characters should retain the shield AC bonus while using a shield as a weapon. I can't find anything in the PHB about attacking with a shield other than the option in the Shield Master feat. Have I...

I use a spellbook app for Pathfinder as a player. It's much faster than flipping through a hardback. I think that's the only app I've discovered that gives a superior experience to the book/paper/pencil product.

Like: Ease of play and general rules emphasis on the things that matter. Dislike: Lots of balance issues and poorly worded rules suggest a product that was thrown together in a rush.

I've had the same problem; all the pages between the Sorcerer and Entertainer entries have fallen out (~30), and many pages before Sorcerer are close to falling out. I contacted WotC Customer Service. To replace the book, I have to send it back so they can confirm the product is defective. Only...

Would it be a good idea to replace the higher level versions of spells with a scaling mechanism? For example, what if Charm Monster and Charm Person were unified, but with a greater selection of targets at the expense of higher level spell slots? Something similar could be done with the other...

I think it's interesting how divided the poll is. It seems to me that the stat prerequisites don't actually fix any of the problems identified by the supporters of the prerequisites, and they may create additional problems. (A) If a player wants to min/max and abuse the multi-classing system...

Shield is misspelled in the AC subsection. I would like another line for languages. I would also prefer if the sheet were editable.

I like this idea, and I would add that since feats are technically optional, we should not rely upon them to scale the effectiveness of grappling/etc. My understanding of the current incarnation of the rules is that proficiency with Athletics provides a bonus to some strength checks (e.g...

What do you think they look like?

This is a difficult question, but I hope that the designers are thinking about this as they develop the classes. [edit: as opposed to as an after thought.] One idea I remember bandied about earlier in the process was the idea that 1st level characters shouldn't necessarily be the standard...

I think it sounds like you need an additional option beyond Thief and Thug to cover your rogue concept. I'm hoping for something more assassin-ish and swashbuckler/scoundrel/rogue-ish. As far as the question, I've never really liked when parties have disproportionately large numbers of...

I'm OK with Wizards being able to work their way to casting in armor, but it shouldn't be as trivial as taking a level in Fighter. Unarmored magic users have been around a long time, and they're the standard in basically every D&D setting. As to the OP, I think by RAW the cantrips that aren't...

I like the idea of Sorcerer Bloodlines, but there are serious balance issues with the Dragon option in the playtest, as is evident in some session reports. I'm not sure why WotC didn't opt for a more general mage-like Sorcerer for the initial playtest. I'm sure we'll see something like that...

If they want 5e to maintain the classic D&D feel they should return to the classic monsters as well, at least in spirit. It's easy enough to house-rule the blue dragon in either direction (desert to sea or sea to desert), but by making the by-the-book blue dragon the classic, desert-dweeling...

I think it looks more like the D&D Dragon Disciple than a Paladin. (Many people mistakenly viewed the Dragon Disciple as a caster prestige class when it was a warrior prestige class.) Even moreso, I think the D&DN Sorcerer looks like the Pathfinder Sorcerer with the Draconic Bloodline. The...

This is a great idea because (1) it further differentiates humans who should be a diverse group, (2) it parallels the choice for other races between sub-races, and (3) it works with optional skills and feats by simply disallowing those options.

Maybe healing dice could be "advantaged"; roll the dice twice and take the higher total.

The difference between having/not-having a Specialty and Background is pretty significant, even at level 1, and it only gets more significant with higher levels. I would expect a mixed party to play something like a D&D party with power-gamers and casual-gamers, with the former tending to steal...

I agree. I would prefer that the Rogue excel at something closer to Pathfinder's combat maneuvers, especially the Dirty Trick introduced in the Advanced Player Guide. Sneak attack should be an option but not a defining feature of all Rogues.