Search results

I've seen trolls with a half-illithid template applied that were prettier than this mess.

Uhh.. D20 Modern and the 3E Tome of Battle were both WotC products. Neither have anything whatsoever to do with the OGL. I don't really see why you are citing them as part of the advantage of the OGL. I think it indicates that the OGL itself was a bad business decision. Ultimately, the d20...

Bah, i've never seen anything I could call historically authentic in any tabletop RPG I have ever played or read, be it rulebook or setting. What D&D calls "medieval fantasy" is all one big horrible mish-mash of poorly understood medieval trappings pasted onto a non-sensical, anachronistic...

Only if your idea of a character involves "being better than the guy sitting next to me". Why? Why is being better than other people so important? Particularly since it opens the door to abusive and problematic behavior.

You know, comments like this, and some I have seen from you earlier, make it sound like you want min-maxing in D&D. It sounds like you see the ability to create a character that is stronger than the character player by another player as a virtue of the system. I find that ludicrous. Isn't the...

What is so absurd? 3E D&D was horridly imbalanced with classes that simply didn't work, Pathfinder is loaded with design traps, and from what I heard, BESM isn't very well balanced itself. Did you miss the Druid example from a few pages ago? As another example, the Truenamer class in 3E's Tome...

Okay, your RPG gaming experience does consist primarily of really heavily unbalanced d20 system games. I am pretty confident now that you have never really played enough truly balanced games to be able to see how much of a difference balance makes. Balance (or the lack, thereof) is something...

It is worth pointing out (for the sake of the overall discussion) that Dash says that at the beginning of the movie, before his character development across the rest of the movie. At the end of the movie, he seems to have a very different perspective. In short, the movie present the idea that...

What games have you been playing? Since I think there is a pretty good possibility that all of your gaming experience comes from playing fundamentally unbalanced games and you just got used to putting in a lot of effort to make them work. Good balance is something that is woefully rare in this...

First off, ability scores are a pretty awful form of simulation. They are so heavily abstracted that no two people can agree on what a 13 in Charisma actually means in-universe. The quantities they are representing are too abstract to clearly correlate with anything someone can recognize...

Why don't we just have five quirky, interesting, and balanced classes? That seems like the ideal state to me. You really are presuming a correlation between balanced and boring that simply isn't true. Plenty of games have pulled off both balanced and interesting at the same time. Heck, even...

That is a very good argument for completely ditching ability scores because they are a lousy mechanic that serves no purpose except to cause serious imbalance by being a significant source of trap options with clear "best" options. I could get behind a change like that in D&D, and I have seen a...

Balance is damn important, and absolutely will not happen by fortuitous accident. There really is no good excuse for a game to be released in this day and age that is not balanced except for sheer developer incompetence. Excusing bad balance is just that: making excuses for obvious problems...

To be honest, I don't really care if the schism continues. There is nothing unnatural or wrong about people playing different games that appeal to their individual tastes. In fact, I consider it a better situation than one where there is only one game in town. I don't think repairing the schism...

It is much more complicated than existing rest rules, and ultimately doesn't really solve the 5MW problem. At its heart, the problem with the 5MW isn't the exact amount of time lost, it is that the pacing of an adventure is broken by the party having to leave and rest up after every encounter...

I chose the "do not want to participate" option. Right now, there are so many endemic problems with the ability score system that it needs some rather significant over-hauling from the ground up. In light of that, an issue with how ability scores scale seems rather inconsequential. Heck, the...

No. The hit point/healing issue is a minor thing that only a handful of people get up in arms about. Usually, it is nothing more than a footnote in the linear fighter/quadratic wizard debate. The entire reason people get up in arms about Warlord healing is a subset of the linear...

Well it is true that a business can't survive on producing RPG books alone. All of the big companies have more reliable income in addition to their RPG business. Most notably, D&D is far and away a secondary product for WotC, who makes a ton of money off of Magic: the Gathering and related card...

The problem with quadratic wizard/linear fighter is that I find it so utterly abhorrent that I won't even give a second glance to a game that doesn't at least recognize it as a problem. This isn't a minor issue, or a matter of style variation that I consider acceptable with a game, it is...

Wait, are you actually saying that swords were the main weapons knights used? I hate to break it to you, but a swords were fairly useless on the battlefields of medieval Europe. A sword, particularly a slashing sword, is primarily effective against unarmored or lightly armored opponents. For...