Search results

That is not what the fallacy is, the fallacy is about a perceived authority, not an actual authority. What you are describing are actual authorities, not perceived authorities.

Exactly, the DM, and players agree on the game they are going to play ideally before the game starts. Less than ideal, but perfectly acceptable and far more common is to work through the incompatible play and arrive at a great game in spite of play style incompatibilities. Communication is...

I identify it as I stated, it is an attempt to protect the players from themselves, especially when they miss the cues that say your choice of combat, or diving into lava et al is an inescapable death sentence in this particular interaction.

There is a reason the phrase "Are you SURE you want to do that?" is a mantra in D&D. DM control is as much about saving players from themselves as it is anything else. Few DM'S relish a TPK, but players try to off themselves with surprising regularity.

Haggling is still very much used in modern society, it has just taken the form of coupons, app discounts, member discounts, employment discounts et al. The haggle is knowing what is available and asking for it.

I believe the inverse is far more true.

It is available as on Kindle and audible, I have it in all 3 formats. I "read" it via audible, and use the book and e book for reference. Also not all 11 year old are the same, young people have time and drive so if they are interested in a subject the more "advanced" information is better...

I got a lot out of these books when I started DMing more than the odd one shot the last couple of years, friends getting into DMing have found the useful as well. "The Lazy DM's" series of books by Michael Shea. "The Monsters Know What They're Doing" series by Keith Ammann. "So You Want To...

Wizbro is no better in that sense, heck they have been caught REMOVING credits from publications gotta love digital media! Let's not forget creating is not the same as owning 😉

Regardless of how flawed early D&D was, his greatest contribution to modern gaming has little to do with that. What is important is how he worked to get it to be the most recognizable TTRPG. Live him or hate him (and there are many valid reasons for both) he made that happen, did he have help...

LOL's, not getting sucked into a circular debate with you again. 😉 Good Day.

I think it came out after D&D didn't it?

And what would their games look like?

True, but what would TTRPG'S and everything that has spun off of D&D look like had he stuck with cobbling shoes? For better or worse he was the reason we got D&D. Leadership matters.

If we all agree all the time life wouldn't be better, it would be worse.

I gave you a starting place, dig in I will not do your research for you😉. Their initial plan was not disclosed until days before rollout, their marketing in the many videos for over a year with Perkins et al stating we had nothing to worry about and then we did if we were not going to adopt...

There are plenty of threads and announcements on DDB, I'd suggest starting here https://www.dndbeyond.com/changelog#UpdatingtheDDBeyondToolsetforthe2024CoreRulebooks and here...

Many, many times. Though they didn't say what level of support, and when they said compendium only and you were going to have to homebrew 100's of things in just a few days is when the excrement hit the air mover.

I have hopes for this direction, but I will not be pre-ordering. It's gonna be wait and see for me, hard covers and quality usable content with good reviews are key to getting me to open my purse.

The fix will likely both be free and unannounced "eratta", less pushback that way. I'm sure the 5.5 phb roll out on DDB is far from forgotten by those incharge of implementations like this. It will be easier to do it like they did the market place, than risk a last minute revolt again.