10 Adventures: Which Ones Should I Get?

[Knightfall]

BTW -- you should check out some of the old Monkey God adventures, they're fun too.

I have a few of those already.

 

[Knightfall]

Fiery Dragon published a 3.5 pdf update at one point, although I don't think it's currently being sold. I was pretty happy with the flavor.

I've been commissioned by Diaglo to finally write a sequel (for OD&D! I'll probably do a 4e appendix, though), so I'm going to try and talk FPD into making the original PDF available for sale again when the sequel comes out in late summer.

Sweet!

See if you can get FDP to make the 3.5 PDF available as a POD book on Lulu.com. I hope the sequel will be as well. Try to add a Pathfinder appendix too. Heh.

 

[Treebore]

All of the modules you have listed are "good", but in my mind "Vindication" and "The Bonegarden" stand out for original ideas that threw nice curves at my players standard expectations.

I only played through a few parts of "Of Sound Mind", and nothing I encountered stood out as truly original or neat, but I also never bought it to read, so do not know what I missed, since I moved away before the DM finished it. I do know the follow up comments I got from my old gaming buddies were very positive about it.

 

[Treebore]

I voted for The Banewarrens. Even if you don't run the complete thing, it offers a lot of cool ideas.

And any adventure taking place in Ptolus using quite some Ptolusitish elements deserves a place in your library.

I played through the Banewarrens, and then later bought and read it. I would say its solid, and definitely has a lot worth mining from it. I never became a huge fan of Ptolus either.

 

[Treebore]

BTW, I believe I posted a review of Bonegarden on ENWorld, long ago. Maybe Vindication too. In the reviews section. I think I am Grimaryl Atyar in reviews, but I also remember eventually doing some as Treebore, but don't remember what products I did that with.

 

[Knightfall]

I voted for The Banewarrens. Even if you don't run the complete thing, it offers a lot of cool ideas.

And any adventure taking place in Ptolus using quite some Ptolusitish elements deserves a place in your library.

Sold!

 

[ruemere]

Banewarrens (comes free with Ptolus book, you may want to order both).
Bonegarden.

Both very recommendable.

Regards,
Ruemere

 

[Knightfall]

Banewarrens (comes free with Ptolus book, you may want to order both).

Regarding Ptolus reference...

I've tried, believe me I've tried.

 

[Thanael]

Do you mean you try to get the Ptolus book? It is readily available at ebay.com for around US $ 125 - US $ 140.

 

[Jeff Wilder]

While we couldn't finish Banewarrens -- I think it was just bad timing, as several of the players in the group had just finished another massive dungeon crawl in RttToEE -- as the DM I really liked it. The NPCs and plot ideas had me considering Ptolus, even though I don't much care for Ptolus's overall flavor.

I'm not familiar with those two DCCs, but I haven't bought a DCC I'm truly disappointed with.

I'm almost certain that I own and have read Demon God's Fane, but if so it wasn't very memorable.