2006 WotC D&D Product Survivor - Round 7

[Glyfair]

Fantastic Locations: Fields of Ruin (again, most comments have focused on the miniatures ties) and Player's Guide to Eberron (objections to material DMs want to keep from the players and optional material without disclaimers saying its optional) got the most votes next round. Given the landslide I can probably pick one of the winner's this round, but will that change?

Vote for the product you think least deserves to be on the "WotC's best D&D products of 2006" list. I ask everyone to vote based on the product's virtues, rather than any side agendas (such as campaign world, cover artists, etc). Yet again, the top 2 vote-getters will be removed.

 

[Crothian]

The one thing these threads have taught me is people hate books for the oddest of reasons.

 

[Nightfall]

The one thing these threads have taught me is people hate books for the oddest of reasons.

Yeah well I hate Red Hand of doom so

 

[Dog Moon]

Yeah well I hate Red Hand of doom so

But only because Nightfall hates the color Red.

 

[Nightfall]

Dog,

No I just think it's a damn silly waste of time chasing Tiamat's spawn and her half breed children when you could easily a) go down into Hell and then b) fight Tiamat.

 

[Dog Moon]

Dog,

No I just think it's a damn silly waste of time chasing Tiamat's spawn and her half breed children when you could easily a) go down into Hell and then b) fight Tiamat.

A. Those are two highly different level of adventures. Perhaps the one could lead into the other.

B. I was playing off of what Crothian said about hating books for the oddest of reasons.

 

[Nightfall]

B) Okay I get b but I was more interested in responding to a)

It might be different levels but the thing is, it would have made the adventure way more interesting than it was.

 

[Dog Moon]

B) Okay I get b but I was more interested in responding to a)

It might be different levels but the thing is, it would have made the adventure way more interesting than it was.

I haven't actually gone through. One person in my group bought it, read it, really liked it, but hasn't yet run it... which, except for the last reason, is why I never looked at it thoroughly cause I didn't want to spoil everything.

 

[Nightfall]

Dog,

Trust me. It might work for you. It didn't work for me. I'll stick with Dungeon, Necromancer Games and Goodman games for my mods.

 

[Dog Moon]

Dog,

Trust me. It might work for you. It didn't work for me. I'll stick with Dungeon, Necromancer Games and Goodman games for my mods.

We'll see if it ever guts run first...

I do plan on running Castle Ravenloft shortly. Hope THAT'S a good adventure. Seems pretty cool from what I've seen.