B/X Known World
If you prefer, go ahead. It stops being a game at that point as there’s no randomness or chance. To me, that’s no different than story time…which I have professional writers and storytellers for. Not Referees, DMs, or GMs. The Referee generally does decide quite a lot. But the mechanics for dice exist for those times when the outcome isn’t obvious from the fiction.Roll 2d6 being our rule in this case. How about simply - GM decides?