D&D 5E 5E Survivor - Proficiencies

[clash]

I'll bite

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Brewer's Supplies 3-2=1
Calligrapher’s Supplies 14
Cartographer's Tools 12
Cook’s Utensils 12
Disguise Kit 10+1=11
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 9

 

[Peter BOSCO'S]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Brewer's Supplies 1 - 2 = GONE (Go home, Brewer's Supplier, you are drunk.)
Calligrapher’s Supplies 14
Cartographer's Tools 12
Cook’s Utensils 12
Disguise Kit 11
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 9 + 1 = 10 (We need Survival skill to help the Exploration pillar of the game.)

 

[AnotherGuy]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 14
Cartographer's Tools 12+1=13
Cook’s Utensils 12
Disguise Kit 11
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 10-2=8

 

[CleverNickName]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 14
Cartographer's Tools 13
Cook’s Utensils 12
Disguise Kit 11-2=9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 8+1=9

Given a choice between cosplay and camping, I'd choose camping.

Spoiler: Fun fact

I was a real-life cartographer for my first few years out of college in the early 90s, before I went to engineering school. I worked for a surveying company, and I drew the plats and maps from the survey data they collected. I still have my school set of "cartographer's tools" somewhere in storage, but nobody uses them anymore. Heck, they probably don't even teach students how to use them anymore. Nowadays, it's all done with ArcInfo GIS or AutoCAD Civil3D. Cartography students today (and RPG authors, apparently) wouldn't know the difference between a divider and a set of "calipers."

 

[The Glen]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 15 As a forever DM I really appreciate good handwriting
Cartographer's Tools 13
Cook’s Utensils 12
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 7 The time of the Skill is over. The time of the Tool has begun

 

[EzekielRaiden]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 15
Cartographer's Tools 13
Cook’s Utensils 12 + 1 = 13 As simply a home cook, I've come to appreciate the value of good tools.
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 7 - 2 = 5 It's the final skill, so the name is apt. But I don't think it should win overall.

 

[Aldarc]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 15
Cartographer's Tools 13
Cook’s Utensils 13+1 = 14 @EzekielRaiden made a fair point here.
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 5-2 = 3 You won't survive!

 

[Tonguez]

Who would have thought a pack of skillless tools would dominate!

 

[ragnodimaggio]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 15
Cartographer's Tools 13-2 = 11
Cook’s Utensils 14
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 3+1 = 4

 

[OB1]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 15-2=13
Cartographer's Tools 11
Cook’s Utensils 14
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 4+1=5 I mean, it is a Survivor thread!

 

[see]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 11
Cartographer's Tools 11
Cook’s Utensils 15
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 5

 

[Maxperson]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 9
Cartographer's Tools 11
Cook’s Utensils 15
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 6

 

[Maxperson]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 15-2=13
Cartographer's Tools 11
Cook’s Utensils 14
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 4+1=5 I mean, it is a Survivor thread!

And it's the only actual skill left! It has two things going for it.

 

[delph]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 9
Cartographer's Tools 9
Cook’s Utensils 16
Disguise Kit 9
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 6

 

[Vaalingrade]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 9
Cartographer's Tools 9
Cook’s Utensils 16
Disguise Kit 9 + 1 = 10
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 6 - 2 = 4 You go away until someone makes exploration fun instead of boring logistics to not die.

 

[Tonguez]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 9
Cartographer's Tools 9
Cook’s Utensils 14 - true adventurers cook on their shields !
Disguise Kit 910
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 5

 

[Undrave]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 9-2=7
Cartographer's Tools 9
Cook’s Utensils 14
Disguise Kit 10
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 5+1=6

 

[CreamCloud0]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 7 - 2 = 5
Cartographer's Tools 9
Cook’s Utensils 14
Disguise Kit 10
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 6 + 1 = 7

 

[Argyle King]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
~Calligrapher’s Supplies 5 - 2 = 3~
~Cartographer's Tools 9 + 1 = 10~
Cook’s Utensils 14
Disguise Kit 10
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 7

 

[chrisrtld]

Alchemist's Supplies 13
Calligrapher’s Supplies 4
Cartographer's Tools 10
Cook’s Utensils 12
Disguise Kit 10
Herbalism Kit 8
Survival 7