6 npc designer reviews at the same time

[Vascant]

Thanks, DonTadow, Rom, and Porge for the reviews.

The rest be advised... well, Mark gave you the idea.

I hope you are doing more then advising from here, a thread that I do not think any of them have even posted in.

 

[Psion]

I hope you are doing more then advising from here, a thread that I do not think any of them have even posted in.

I know some of them are posters here.

Alas, probably not the ones that need advised.

At any rate, ignorance is not excuse for the law.

 

[DonTadow]

I know they meant their best, but I feel like if you're going to open up your mouth about a product you enjoyed, say as much about it as you can good and bad. I highschool teacher used to tell me to never waste a word. If you dont get a point across when you speak, why are you opening your mouth.

In their defense, It seems the shorter reviews are reminicent of the ones you find at rpgnow, which is acceptabile for their rules policy, however, they certainly don't fit the enworld format.

 

[Vascant]

Will it remove the reviews if I remove the product?

 

[Mark CMG]

Will it remove the reviews if I remove the product?

Leave it to Psion to deal with. He's got it in hand and you should just leave it at that. It isn't hurting anything and it happens often enough that there is a system in place.

 

[rom90125]

I guess I need to find out what merits an acceptable review from the ENWorlders...My review was not meant to be a rehash of the more verbose reviews given by DonTadow and Porge but a snapshot of why I feel NPC Designer is superior to other npc generators I've used. If anyone feels that my review in anyway was bought and paid for by RPGAttitude because a post Vascant made at his site, then I wish to explicitly state that this was not the case. For those that have the ability to search these forums, please take a look at my other posts regarding NPC Designer and the work Vascant has done. I've been an advocate of this product for some time now, and I've stated as much in the few posts I've made. As you can see, my post count is relatively low (and even lower on RPGAttitudes boards) but, that is because I don't drop frivolous posts very often and I generally will only post if I feel I have something to add to the dialogue. This was the approach I took when I decided to post a review of NPC Designer...I had read the previous reviews and felt it would be a disservice to everyone if I rehashed what was already said.

Edit: cleaned up my p!ss poor spelling...

 

[lior_shapira]

Vascant, if you were referring to my original post as suggesting to a scam, then that's a little paranoid. All I said, is that its a little weird seeing six reviews at the same time, especially when some of them aren't really reviews, as others have pointed out. I personally, in the 3(more or less) years I've been visiting ENWorld, never saw so many reviews posted for one product in such a short time.

I actually did download the demo of your product and play with it a little after I posted, although my opinion on it isn't relevant at all to the discussion.

lior s.

 

[Psion]

I guess I need to find out what merits an acceptable review from the ENWorlders...My review was not meant to be a rehash of the more verbose reviews given by DonTadow and Porge but a snapshot of why I feel NPC Designer is superior to other npc generators I've used.

Your review was fine; I wouldn't sweat it.

Crothian or I have posted a response in each of the reviews that we are concerned about.

 

[rom90125]

Psion, Thanks for the update.

 

[Vascant]

Vascant, if you were referring to my original post as suggesting to a scam, then that's a little paranoid. All I said, is that its a little weird seeing six reviews at the same time, especially when some of them aren't really reviews, as others have pointed out. I personally, in the 3(more or less) years I've been visiting ENWorld, never saw so many reviews posted for one product in such a short time.

This post came on the heels of two other threads in the Publisher's forum. Am I am paranoid, no.. but I do know people post things without thought to the damage. If you really had a concern, just go to Meta because if I was "up to something" it would be very easy to tell but to post in a general forum, just tacky and drama. ENWorld also has ENGS for the first time in three years.

You never know, maybe the next time someone does something a little different people might be a bit more open minded. Yesterday just showed me something I didn't like, by the end of the day I spent 5 hours dealing with drama when I could have been using those hours creating something better for the people that posted reviews or in threads. so the question to me, or for me, is do I quit selling so I can focus my time on coding and creating something better for the people who do enjoy and get use out of NPC Designer? I have a great customer base and they deserve better