A cheap alternative to Campaign Coins

Morrus

Well, that was fun
Staff member
I was looking at the Campaign Coins on Paizo's website, but to get enough to last an entire 1-20 level adventure path you'd have to spend a fortune. Plus half of them are out of stock.

But then I looked at eBay instead. And started looking at plastic coins. And I found you could buy hundreds and hundreds of them in different sizes and in gold or silver colours for a pittance. Some are based on real-world currencies (like kids' pretend money), but a lot are pirate-themed and the like. Use the larger sizes as larger denominations, and you can pick up enough to last you forever and spend less than you would on a new book.

Then I got even more adventurous. I found toy plastic gold and silver bullion bars, tons of cheap toy or fake gemstones, and more. So I grabbed 10 each of a few different colours (clear, green, white, black, blue, red, etc.) I'd still spent almost nothing.

And then I bought a kid's toy pirate treasure chest for under a fiver to keep them all in.

None of this stuff has arrived yet, but when my massive haul of treasure arrives I'll post a picture. When I run my next campaign, I'll buy a drawstring bag/pouch for each of my players to keep their money in, and when they loot a guard's corpse, I'll be able able to say "You find this pouch" and throw a sall puch with assorted coins and gems onto the table and let them divide it up how they want.

I did this when I ran Age of Worms a couple of years ago, but I was using printed-out card money, which isn't the same. I combined that with Paizo's item card sets, and we had a rule "If you don't have it, you don't have it". Money and equipment counts itself just by virtue of existing. If anyone says "Oh, I gave that potion to him before the fight started" I can say "Did you? Who has the card?", and when the players are shopping I can literally sell an item card for coins or gems, or when a player drinks a potion, he hands to card back to me.

I find it really does add a level of immersion. It reduces accounting. And it's fun. Finding treasure feels like finding treasure.

I'm not running a campaign right now, but next time I do, I'm gonna go prop-tastic with it. It's gonna be a blast!

I might look for some toy plastic necklaces and rings and stuff now. Not for magic items, but for assorted treasure trinkets.
 

Attachments

  • 1104937969174040_1.jpg
    1104937969174040_1.jpg
    9.7 KB · Views: 2,168
  • 1506056667424040_1.jpg
    1506056667424040_1.jpg
    3.4 KB · Views: 2,104
  • 1306554895934040_1.jpg
    1306554895934040_1.jpg
    2.2 KB · Views: 2,113
  • 1208721903124040_1.jpg
    1208721903124040_1.jpg
    5.5 KB · Views: 2,182
  • 1208258218804040_1.jpg
    1208258218804040_1.jpg
    2.2 KB · Views: 2,130
  • 1108266870264040_1.jpg
    1108266870264040_1.jpg
    12.9 KB · Views: 2,148
  • 1607548955104040_1.jpg
    1607548955104040_1.jpg
    5.2 KB · Views: 2,100
  • 2704569016454040_6.jpg
    2704569016454040_6.jpg
    3.5 KB · Views: 2,093
  • 3505263126214040_1.jpg
    3505263126214040_1.jpg
    5.7 KB · Views: 2,085
  • 2006784033534040002_1.jpg
    2006784033534040002_1.jpg
    8.2 KB · Views: 2,077
  • 1107319308684040_1.jpg
    1107319308684040_1.jpg
    5.7 KB · Views: 2,083
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

My players adamantly hate props. I couldn't sell them on this if I was dying. Every time I created a card or prop, they'd just write on their character sheet and toss it back to me.
 


I love the idea, but I can't imagine my players coming from work to the pub (The Counting House!) with a sack of plastic bullion... I'm lucky if some of them bring their character sheets*! :D

*When I play, I leave mine with the DM just in case...
 

Get some Mardi Gras doubloons. You'll love 'em. You can buy them from collectors or from the stores that supply the krewes. However, you'll probably want to stick to the plastic or aluminum- the ones made of bronze, silver and gold are as expensive as you'd think.

Yes, they're ALL probably more expensive than I think you'd want to spend- $8 for 50 or $12 for 100 is as cheap as I've seen- but handing them out for special treasure could work.

For example:

Mardi Gras Doubloons and Cups

Aluminum Mardi Gras Krewe Doubloons [82601AL] - $7.65 : Mardi Gras Beads | Mardi Gras Decorations | Mardi Gras Mask | Mardi Gras Supplies

Accent Annex- the second link- is one I know pretty well: we used to drive by it all the timeon visits to relatives when I was a kid, and we'd get stuff there for parties.
 

Get some Mardi Gras doubloons. You'll love 'em. You can buy them from collectors or from the stores that supply the krewes. However, you'll probably want to stick to the plastic or aluminum- the ones made of bronze, silver and gold are as expensive as you'd think.

Yes, they're ALL probably more expensive than I think you'd want to spend- $8 for 50 or $12 for 100 is as cheap as I've seen- but handing them out for special treasure could work.

For example:

Mardi Gras Doubloons and Cups

Aluminum Mardi Gras Krewe Doubloons [82601AL] - $7.65 : Mardi Gras Beads | Mardi Gras Decorations | Mardi Gras Mask | Mardi Gras Supplies

Accent Annex- the second link- is one I know pretty well: we used to drive by it all the timeon visits to relatives when I was a kid, and we'd get stuff there for parties.

They do look cool. I wonder if I can find them in the UK?
 

The company that makes campaign coins did see to overlook the important fact that most campaigns are going to require oodles and oodles of coins. The company website talks about high quality coins, but low quality is the name of the game. That, and having a 1000 cp copper coin just kind of defeat the point of having physical representation for 1000 copper pieces... I think the same sort of cardstock that monster counters are made out of would be ideal, or if you want something physical but abstract, maybe a card machine like they use in the new electronic Monopoly.
 

The company that makes campaign coins did see to overlook the important fact that most campaigns are going to require oodles and oodles of coins. The company website talks about high quality coins, but low quality is the name of the game. That, and having a 1000 cp copper coin just kind of defeat the point of having physical representation for 1000 copper pieces... I think the same sort of cardstock that monster counters are made out of would be ideal, or if you want something physical but abstract, maybe a card machine like they use in the new electronic Monopoly.

Why would I want cardboard coins when I've just bought hundreds of plastic ones for less than price of a coffee? :D
 
Last edited:

I would be surprised if they didn't ship overseas...for how much, though, I cannot even speculate.

Or you could just go to New Orleans next year and get your own! ;)

That, BTW, is an insane spectacle- adults of all ages turning into hockey enforcers as they scramble for fake coins and cheap plastic beads. Worse if they happen to be going after some of the rarer "throws", like Zulu coconuts.
 
Last edited:

I recently bought some fake plastic coins (they are intended to help learn to count money) to use in a game. Currently, I only have one pack. I've been experimenting with painting some of them using mini paint. Once I have a design that I like, I plan to buy more.

It couldn't hurt to broaden my search though. I have not put much effort into the idea yet. I simply saw the pack of coins at a local store and decided to see what I could do with them. A Google search and buying bulk online might be the better path for me to take.
 

Remove ads

Top