• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

A question about TV sets...

sfgiants

First Post
I know this may not be the best place for this, but... anyways I am looking to buy a big screen tv and the amount of information out there is immense...So I figured I would come to the knowlege filled message boards of EN World. Anyways, a few questions:

a) what is the difference between lcd and dlp?
b) any preference? which is better?
c) any good brands? any ones to avoid?
d) any good web sites with info on this topic?

Personal experience with a product is welcome!
 

log in or register to remove this ad

sfgiants said:
a) what is the difference between lcd and dlp?
b) any preference? which is better?
c) any good brands? any ones to avoid?
d) any good web sites with info on this topic?

For your first question, the difference is primarilly in the way that the image is created:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DLP and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LCD give brief rundowns. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_display_technology gives a (very) brief comparison of all standards.

When I sold electronics (for Sears, if you must know) I had the opportunity to see many different LCD and DLP televisions, and my general impression is that DLP is better. It really depends more on the quality of the manufacturer though. A crappy manufacturer will make a crappy tv, no matter what technology they use. That said, DLP sets, IMO, tend to be crisper than LCD, especially with motion. Also, DLP sets don't tend to have as big a problem with angled viewing as LCD monitors do, IMO. Again though, high-end LCD screens won't have these problems as much, reducing the difference between the two.

Another big issue is how long they'll last. LCD screens will start to fade after a few years. DLP screens won't have this problem, though you might have to change the bulb. This can be easy or difficult to do, depending on the brand and model, and is something to check out. The bulbs are also expensive, but I never had to replace one, so I can't speak to how much they run for. In my experience, they don't need to be changed so often as to make this a huge issue though. Last I knew, it was something like every 8000 hours, which even if you leave your TV on 24/7 is about once a year.

Avoid low-end brands. When you begin thinking about spending serious money on a television set, it becomes more of an investment, and it's worthwhile to spend as much as you can comfortably afford to get what you want. I'd recommend staying away from the American brands, as they haven't caught up to the Japanese companies at all. What brands you like tends to be a personal thing, tied into what brands you've had experience with in the past, and how well they performed. Personally, I like the Samsung DLPs, though Toshiba makes some nice televisions (both DLP and LCD). I'll freely admit to being a Sony fanboy, but they don't seem to be as interested in the big screen market as others.

One big caveat is that LCD screens actually perform best around 22", which is certainly not the size for a big-screen television. DLP on the other hand works best at 40" and up. Keep this in mind when you're reading reviews - hopefully, a good review will note this. LCD screens lose a lot of brightness and contrast the bigger they get.

Anyway, I hope that's a little bit useful. I don't have any good websites that dissect it in more detail, but a simple google search for the two terms should bring up a wealth of information, especially with regards to comparisons.
 

LP has similar experience to myself so I'll just say that he's on the money with LCD vs. DLP. When I do get a bigger TV I'll probably opt to not go with LCD as the price for the unit + potential repairs and burn-in kinda scares me away a bit. If I'm already spending that much money I'd certainly rather pour a few more bucks into making the space for the TV (projection area?) a priority. That can make a huge difference.

I used to work at Circuit City (for about 3 years) and people always went for brand and I agree completely. When I decided to upgrade my TV I did a bunch of research. I wasn't getting a big screen because the space I have isn't much. I was looking for something around 30-35 inches. Ended up getting a 16x9 Sony. Great purchase.

The sites I go to are the following:

cnet.com - http://reviews.cnet.com/4520-6463_7-5023901.html?tag=belt.tv

SatelliteGuys.US - http://radio.satelliteguys.us/index.php?

Hi Def Forum - http://www.highdefforum.com/

DHTVarcade.com - http://www.hdtvarcade.com/hdtvforum/

I browse the forums and see what people are getting, what they are using it for and how it's worked out.

Personally, I have found that I don't mind spending the premium price on the Sony brand. You really can't go wrong with them even though their prices may be 5-10% higher than the exact same product from another company. As for TVs alone I'd recommend Sony or Samsung above all others. They have the most experience making them and so many people own them that it's easier to get tech help if need be.

There are many folks who will tell you to stay away from Sony. They'll say things like they've worked in repairs or seen so many defective models or somesuch. There is a reason for this: They sell more product than anyone else! I used to walk through the repair center and see all types of Sony stuff laying around and less of other brands (more notably Panasonic) but when viewing the units I always liked the look of their displays. If you were buying a smaller TV I'd say that Panasonic is ok but you are looking for something bigger so stick with Sony/Samsung. Now I will add that I haven't been shopping for a TV in about a year so Panasonic's larger stuff may have increased in quality. The sites I linked should help with that. :)
 
Last edited:

The web sites the other two posters have noted are good. I've used them myself. DLP is the way to go. The color and picture is so much better than LCD that it is very easy to see the difference. Also you don't have to worry about "burn ins" like the stations logo at the bottom of the screen as much.

I work in the cable industry and see a lot of tvs. The one I see the most is Sony. I have done quite a bit of research (as I'm buying a new HDTV next month) and from what I've read Sony seems to be one of the higher rated ones in DLP. Hitachi is rated the highest in LCD. Hitachi makes most of the light guns that go into most brands of LCD HDTVs but make a higher grade light gun for themselves.

Another thing to look at if you get a LCD is does it have a digital tuner? Don't get it. Your local cable Co. should offer HDTV with DVR sevice. Ther is your dual digital tuner with Tivo like functions. then you can put the money you save on the tuner into a bigger screen. :cool: AFAIK all DLPs come with a digital tuner.

One other thing....Ask your local TV dealer when he is running a sale. Mine said that Sony usually runs a sale in the fall on TVS so that they can clear out inventory for the new stuff that comes out at Christmas.

Hope this helps.

PS. Stay away from Plasma......Nothing but junk IMHO.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top