• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

A warm welcome to the return of Thomas Covenant and Linden Avery

So very cool to see a TC thread here. I have grown up reading, and rereading the first two chronicles. I finished the book a few months ago and while it was very satisfying (much like listening to a favorite cd you haven't heard in awhile) I too was a bit disillusioned when finishing the book. Don't get me wrong, although I was more than grateful for a new TC-related story from SRD, I felt Runes was a series of jumps from one short story to the next with no real cohesion in between. Again, I STRONGLY recommend this book to any TC fan. Knowing there are going to be three more books has me believing that SRD has great things in store for Linden and her companions...
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Andre said:
Not sure if this is what you want, but here are several that are just beginning to discuss the new series:

http://com1.runboard.com/bthescribesmessageboard.freaderscorner.t162

http://messageboard.cinescape.com/c...p?Cat=&Board=UBB118&Number=187708&Main=170894

http://forums.livingwithstyle.com/archive/index.php/t-103687.html

http://www.sffworld.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-2191.html

Here's the most interesting comment I've seen so far:

The fact that Donaldson has selected ths final 4 books to be "Foul's Story" is great. He says he will answer the questions about why Foul became the lord of despair. He made a great comment that Foul is, himself, despairing and in pain, and in order to know why he does what he does we need to learn how he became who he is.

Now, that sounds interesting...

What do you think the odds are that Foul is Covenant?
 

woooo...now that would be evil. Linden having to face off against Foul-Covenant. Damn, I'd have to go with Covenant on that one. He could really bring the 'hate'...
 

Thank you, Andre! Thank you very much! :)

I would say this about Runes of the Earth: it demands of the reader a little of what it demands of Linden Avery.
Runes of the Earth presents an unending series of questions. And each answer to each question, generates 3 more questions. And this goes on for hundreds of pages.

Linden Avery must confront an endless series of questions and find the answers. But the answers are elusive, complicated, frustrating, and hard won.

Well, the author demands a bit of this from the reader. There is no instant gratification here. There is action, but not the sweeping, book-long action of a John Carter novel (I liked the John Carter series; this is simply a different type of writing) Answers require the readers' patience, and like Linden Avery, the reader will find frustration in dealing with the maddening wait for those answers, and the more maddening implications of those answers - that they lead to more questions.

If patience is a virtue (and in the Land, it is) then certainly patience will reward the reader of the Runes of the Earth.
If careful study and earned insight are important (and they are very important in the Land: unearned insight is a disaster there) then studious reading and studied reading of this book pays off for the reader. This is not a book to scan through swiftly, or to practice ones' speed reading on.
If understanding other people, and not rushing to rash judgements is important (and in the Land, they are important) then once again the reader will find the most reward in the rich characters and lush histories given in the book, drawing the reader in until he is living and breathing the Land and the story set within it. But for those who wish a hurry up story with scant attention paid to character development, this book will be a study in frustration.

I ask those who have already read Runes of the Earth (I am up to page 425 in it) if I am not correct?

Edena_of_Neith
 
Last edited:

Edena_of_Neith said:
I ask those who have already read Runes of the Earth (I am up to page 425 in it) if I am not correct?

Well, if you're right, then we'll have to be very patient. The answers must be in the next three volumes (though I suspect that they'll seem obvious in hindsight...)
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top