D&D 5E actual encounter [high-level play]

[Tony Vargas]

Could I inconvenience you to provide a teensy bit more detail about this?

They're guessing at locations they can't see, but can reach, right? How many different places could the target be? that's n. It's in 1 of them. 1:n chance. Roll dice to approximate that.

Incorporeal, like a specter for example.
Logically, to me at least, the reason for their immunity to "grappled" is because they're incorporeal, because when you attempt your grapple your hands pass right through (possibly not without harm, but still)... I ruled you could pass thru the square, but that the spectral berserker got its OA (despite the rules saying you don't threaten if you can't see).

Sounds good to me.

 

[hawkeyefan]

I'd still make the warlock make a stealth check. The demons would have disadvantage to notice him. I'd allow the demons to move through spaces occupied by the spectral dwarves.

I think that regarding random attacks at the warlock, I'd use a die roll to determine randomly or I'd have the demons' attacks hit the spectral dwarves rather than the PC. I could see myself making either call during play.

 

[CapnZapp]

thx