Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 6325096" data-attributes="member: 22779">No, it is certainly not besides the point.  What you are asking for has never really existed in D&D.  In fact, it runs specifically counter to the express interpretations of HP in at least AD&D.  Every edition has had monks, which grant non-magical healing as an ability.  So, right off the bat, you're into an interpretation that has never actually been supported in any way, shape or form in any version of D&D.  In 2ed, if you had the Heal NWP, you could grant 1d4+1 HP to anyone if applied shortly after a fight ended.  So, for at least since 2e, you could regain HP through non-magical means simply through a proficiency.I'd be shocked if there wasn't something similar buried in the 3e rules.  Even the complete rest rules allowed for 2hp/level/day without a check, 4 with.  Which meant that wizards always heal in 1 day of rest with help.  Realistically, all but the highest of HP characters would also heal in 1 day or maybe 2.  So, again, why would they have the specific module you are asking for when it has never, ever appeared in any edition of D&D?You claim to want the following:1.  HP as partially meat - HP/WP does this, check.2.  No non-magical healing - HP/WP does this, check.3.  Slow natural recovery of meat - HP/WP does this check.This module does every single thing, covers every single thing that you claim you want.  It may do it in a fashion that isn't 100% like you did it in your game, but, that's a bit unreasonable to expect.  So, again, what more do you want?  You have repeatedly claimed that the Dev's are not providing options for your play style.  This is 100% false.  We KNOW they have a WP/VP in the DMG.  They've specifically called it out.  So, one last time, what more support do you want?</blockquote>

Verification