Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="CovertOps" data-source="post: 4925459" data-attributes="member: 65152">I have nothing else to say if you're not going to try to deny my position.&nbsp; I am going to take your lack of rebuttal as an acceptance that my position is correct.&nbsp; Your comments lead me to believe that you have not even tried to either understand my argument or even bothered to read my posts.&nbsp; You ignore the substance of what I'm saying and just selectively respond to the most insignificant parts.&nbsp; For example your first point is silly if you had read the rules...&quot;Well, by that logic you'd never get an Automatic Hit.&quot;&nbsp; Step 4 of the attack resolution includes 2 FULL PAGES OF RULES ending with the block about hits and misses (which incidentally includes the automatic hit rule).Artoomis...you really need to sit down one night with your PHB and actually read the whole section.&nbsp; Look at it's organization.&nbsp; Read the steps that you are required to take and then all the supporting rules that go with it.&nbsp; Look at the flow of the rules.&nbsp; You're too focused in on just one particular part.That and despite your best efforts at a denial the critical hit rules are on p278.&nbsp; Assertions to the contrary are unfounded.&nbsp; Try reading the headers above the rules blocks.&nbsp; On p276 the header clearly says &quot;Attack Results&quot; and on p278 you find the header...wait for it......&quot;Critical Hits&quot;.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="CovertOps, post: 4925459, member: 65152"] I have nothing else to say if you're not going to try to deny my position. I am going to take your lack of rebuttal as an acceptance that my position is correct. Your comments lead me to believe that you have not even tried to either understand my argument or even bothered to read my posts. You ignore the substance of what I'm saying and just selectively respond to the most insignificant parts. For example your first point is silly if you had read the rules... "Well, by that logic you'd never get an Automatic Hit." Step 4 of the attack resolution includes 2 FULL PAGES OF RULES ending with the block about hits and misses (which incidentally includes the automatic hit rule). Artoomis...you really need to sit down one night with your PHB and actually read the whole section. Look at it's organization. Read the steps that you are [b]required[/b] to take and then all the supporting rules that go with it. Look at the flow of the rules. You're too focused in on just one particular part. That and despite your best efforts at a denial the critical hit rules are on p278. Assertions to the contrary are unfounded. Try reading the headers above the rules blocks. On p276 the header clearly says "Attack Results" and on p278 you find the header...wait for it......"Critical Hits". [/QUOTE]

Verification