Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="DEFCON 1" data-source="post: 8949078" data-attributes="member: 7006">I know attacking/casting a spell broke it for the Invisibility spell... but I want to say that there were creatures that had invisibility that did not have it break when they attacked.&nbsp; So I don't believe it was a universal truth that all invisibility broke on attacks/spells (with Greater Invisibility the only outlier.)As a result, I would say that indeed the Invisible [condition] should not itself have the rule of it breaking, but rather the different events for which it could break should include the statement.&nbsp; So the Invisibility spell would say that the Invisible [condition] breaks on attack/casting... but Greater Invisibility would not.&nbsp; And monsters who have natural invisibility would not have to have a statement saying that it doesn't break when they attack/cast either.I guess it really depends on what WotC would consider the standard rule-- is the standard meant to be that invisibility always breaks except for special circumstances that call out that it doesn't... or does invisibility not break except for special circumstances that call out that it does?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="DEFCON 1, post: 8949078, member: 7006"] I know attacking/casting a spell broke it for the [I]Invisibility[/I] spell... but I want to say that there were creatures that had invisibility that did not have it break when they attacked. So I don't believe it was a universal truth that all invisibility broke on attacks/spells (with [I]Greater Invisibility[/I] the only outlier.) As a result, I would say that indeed the Invisible [condition] should not itself have the rule of it breaking, but rather the different events for which it could break should include the statement. So the [I]Invisibility[/I] spell would say that the Invisible [condition] breaks on attack/casting... but [I]Greater Invisibility[/I] would not. And monsters who have natural invisibility would not have to have a statement saying that it doesn't break when they attack/cast either. I guess it really depends on what WotC would consider the standard rule-- is the standard meant to be that invisibility always breaks except for special circumstances that call out that it doesn't... or does invisibility not break except for special circumstances that call out that it does? [/QUOTE]

Verification