Man in the Funny Hat said:
I used to drop in at Gary's Games whenever I got in the area for work. Fantastic in Lynnwood too. The owner there was almost TOO gregarious and would talk your ear off if given a chance. You don't mention American Eagles in Lake City though. I think they also still have a store in Tacoma. AE always had more metal minis than anywhere else. When I moved to the south end I actually relied on WotC at South Hill Mall in Puyallup more often than anyplace else.
Course that was all a good 5+ years ago and now I live in CA.
I didn't have my game store list in front of me. Here it is:
YMMV on these shops (and it's as complete a list as I've found):
Fantastic Games & Toys <== This shop moved to Hwy 99 and 224th, near the Ranch 99 store and south of the Payless Shoes store. The former owner Scott was kinda a nut. Don't know about the new folks.
www.fantasticgamesandtoys.com
(425) 775-4871
Suite 204
22617 76th Ave. W.
Edmonds, WA 98026
===
Gary's Games 206-789-8891 <== This shop has a good used game section. The staff aren't too surly (well, the Surly Redhead is).
8539 Greenwood N
Seattle, WA 98103 - 3613
===
Gary's Books & Collectibles <== This is an odd shop, somewhat junk-shoppy but I have found old games here for good prices.
425-258-4233
2531 Broadway Ste H
Everett, WA 98201 - 3020
===
Uncles Games <== Two locations, somewhat limited selection on stuff, but mostly new. No used games.
Unclesgames.com
Bellevue
15600 NE 8th Ave., Suite K10, Bellevue, WA
(425)746-1539
Redmond
16507 NE 74th St., Redmond, WA
(425) 497-9180
===
Genesis Games & Gizmos <== Has some used games last time I was there.
8912 161st Ave Ne, Redmond, WA 98052
phone: (425) 497-9579
http://www.genesisgamesandgizmos.com
===
Oroboro Games & Books <== Used to be Coyote Games, no used games (except sales).
16505 Redmond Way #E
Redmond, WA
Phone: (425) 558-9181
===
American Eagles <== No used games, lots of out of print and hard to find games, but all sold as new, at original prices. Staff is OK, but they've pissed me off on many occasions due to poor service.
Lake City Way
Seattle, WA
===
Game Wizards
Seattle, WA
===
Golden Age Collectables
Pike Place Market
Seattle, WA
===
Games Plus
Woodinville, WA
===
The Dreaming (comics and games)
U District
University Way
Seattle, WA
Also, if you are looking for used games, then try Half Price Books. There are locations in Edmonds, Everett, Bellevue, Seattle Capital Hill, Seattle U District, Southcenter, Tacoma. Also, you can try Third Place Books in Kenmoore.