AD&D 1E Best 1E AD&D rulebook?

[Ralif Redhammer]

TBF most of the monsters you just named originated in modules, and were later reprinted in the FF.

Even if the FF did introduce them to a wider audience, the Underdark had already been populated with all those iconic ones.

That's the thing - the reach of the hardcovers were greater than that of the modules. Back in the day I only had a few AD&D modules, but had almost all of the orange spine releases.

 

[Voadam]

This is really tough, I guess I don't really have a favorite. I could go with anything from Oriental Adventures and above here.

I really really like the art in the PH, DMG, DD&G, MM, FF, and MMII. MM has the Trampier goodness and the DSC devils and demons, FF has the Nicholson weirdness, and MMII has the fantastic non-silly Holloway stuff. MMII really develops the fiendish hierarchies fleshing out devils and demons but also stuff like the demodands and daemons plus celestial types too. Deities and Demigods art is top notch and mostly covers for the paucity of the narrative descriptions accompanying the cool but mostly unusable statblocks, the 2e Legends & Lore and FR god books are my favorite god books in all of D&D, but the 1e Deities & Demigods has better art. The PH and the DMG are just atmospheric, I love the evocative nature of the party seeing the magic mouth.

The monster collections are all cool, each has really stellar standouts.

OA introduced really cool martial arts for any character, so you did not need to be the weird 1e monk based off the crappy thief class chassis but with a lower d4 HD to have decent martial arts techniques in the game. I really liked that as an aspect of AD&D.

In the end I am going with the MMII, the Holloway Demon Lords and Archdevils really do it for me.

 

[sevenbastard]

Fiend folio as it was the first D&D that I bought so I didn't have to borrow from my older brother. Nostalgia trumps all.

In case you haven't seen it before, there's a 1E solo play campaign journal on Dragonsfoot in which the player uses the Fiend Folio tables for all the encounters. Which spices them up a good bit

This is how I ran solo play as a ten year old trying to level my ranger. I got a lot of use out of the tables in the back of the FF for both monsters and treasure

 

[timbannock]

I voted Monster Manual but frankly I view MM, MM2, and Fiend Folio as all equal parts of a whole.

Interesting to see the DMG as #1; it's definitely got the most personality, for so many reasons!