Arnwyn
First Post
I've read comments like this many times on this forum. It seems that some people here (especially DMs) have no personal friendship with the Players in their game. They can say hello and goodbye to the Players like dealing with strangers on the street.
I can't imagine regularly playing with a DM who was so socially disconnected from his fellow players that he would/could casually "show them the door" and bring in someone else that easily. I can't imagine a DM who would not form some kind of friendly bond with the Players. This almost sounds anti-social.
Sure... but then, I can't imagine a friend would "hand in a character sheet after a campaign twist", either. Just as you couldn't imagine a DM who was so socially disconnected from his fellow players that he would/could casually "show them the door" and bring in someone else that easily, I can't imagine a player who would "hand in their character sheet". So, your "especially DMs" comment, and further related comments, seem a bit misleading.
But otherwise, yeah. My vote was #3. I only game with friends.