Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Edena_of_Neith" data-source="post: 4617385" data-attributes="member: 2020">817 votes.&nbsp; &nbsp; Changeover:&nbsp; 32%&nbsp; No Changeover:&nbsp; 58%&nbsp; Partial Changeover:&nbsp; 10%&nbsp; Those choosing Option 6:&nbsp; 30%&nbsp; These results have held steady for the last 200 votes cast, perhaps longer.&nbsp; -&nbsp; I wish to consider an alternative way of looking at this poll, and that is adding Option 5 to the No Changeover Category.&nbsp; This is justified by the fact that Option 2 is in the Changeover Category.&nbsp; Option 2 says:&nbsp; Mostly 4E.&nbsp; Option 5 says mostly Prior Editions.&nbsp; So, why not add Option 5 to the No Changeover category?&nbsp; Or ...&nbsp; &nbsp; Remove Option 2 from the Changeover Category.&nbsp; Here are the results IF Option 5 is added to the No Changeover Category AND Option 2 is retained for the Changeover Category:&nbsp; Changeover:&nbsp; 32%&nbsp; No Changeover:&nbsp; 62%&nbsp; Here are the results IF Option 5 is *not* added to the No Changeover Category AND Option 2 is *not* retained for the Changeover Category:&nbsp; Changeover:&nbsp; 25%&nbsp; No Changeover:&nbsp; 58%&nbsp; Note that a fair number of people have (as you can see) voted for Option 2, and I included in in Changeover.&nbsp; A few people (4%) voted for Option 5, and I did *not* include it in No Changeover.&nbsp; This is my mistake.&nbsp; I can't fix that mistake now, or I create a discontinuity with the First Changeover Poll.&nbsp; I merely wanted to put all this up, for comparison, and - if you wish - analysis.&nbsp; Any way you cut it, though ... the No Changeovers definitely have this poll.&nbsp; &nbsp; I don't know if it's because ENWorld favors earlier editions, or earlier edition people vote more enthusiastically, or if 4E is in trouble, or if the 4E enthusiasts simply didn't bother to vote, or if people have stuffed the ballot box, or whatever ... but I would have to say that in this poll the No Changeovers Have It.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Edena_of_Neith, post: 4617385, member: 2020"] 817 votes. Changeover: 32% No Changeover: 58% Partial Changeover: 10% Those choosing Option 6: 30% These results have held steady for the last 200 votes cast, perhaps longer. - I wish to consider an alternative way of looking at this poll, and that is adding Option 5 to the No Changeover Category. This is justified by the fact that Option 2 is in the Changeover Category. Option 2 says: Mostly 4E. Option 5 says mostly Prior Editions. So, why not add Option 5 to the No Changeover category? Or ... Remove Option 2 from the Changeover Category. Here are the results IF Option 5 is added to the No Changeover Category AND Option 2 is retained for the Changeover Category: Changeover: 32% No Changeover: 62% Here are the results IF Option 5 is *not* added to the No Changeover Category AND Option 2 is *not* retained for the Changeover Category: Changeover: 25% No Changeover: 58% Note that a fair number of people have (as you can see) voted for Option 2, and I included in in Changeover. A few people (4%) voted for Option 5, and I did *not* include it in No Changeover. This is my mistake. I can't fix that mistake now, or I create a discontinuity with the First Changeover Poll. I merely wanted to put all this up, for comparison, and - if you wish - analysis. Any way you cut it, though ... the No Changeovers definitely have this poll. I don't know if it's because ENWorld favors earlier editions, or earlier edition people vote more enthusiastically, or if 4E is in trouble, or if the 4E enthusiasts simply didn't bother to vote, or if people have stuffed the ballot box, or whatever ... but I would have to say that in this poll the No Changeovers Have It. [/QUOTE]

Verification