Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Edena_of_Neith" data-source="post: 4630957" data-attributes="member: 2020">Here are the options in that poll, and their similarity (if any) to the ones here:&nbsp; - Wasn't inspired to try at all&nbsp; (Closest to Option 7, all earlier editions only)&nbsp; - Bought the books but looked crap so never played (Closest to Option 6, tried 4E, returned to earlier editions)&nbsp; - Liked the OP, started off loving but quickly soured (Also closest to Option 6:&nbsp; Tried 4E, returned to earlier editions)&nbsp; - Still playing, rotating with other games/editions (Closest to Options 3, 4, and 5 - Partial Changeover options)&nbsp; - It is still my game of choice and looks to stay that way (Closest to Option 1 (all 4E) and Option 2 (mostly 4E)&nbsp; - Your favourite game sucks (Corresponds with no choice in the Changeover Poll)&nbsp; With that said, their results were:&nbsp; Wasn't inspired to try at all (Equivalent to Option 7)&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 35&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; 11.08%Bought the books but looked crap so never played (Option 6)&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; 23&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 7.28%Like the OP, started off loving but quickly soured (Option 6)&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 42&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 13.29%Still playing, rotating with other games / editions (Options 3, 4, 5)&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; 87&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 27.53%It is still my game of choice and looks to stay that way (Options 1, 2)&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; 120&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 37.97%Your favourite game sucks!&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 9&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; 2.85%&nbsp; Thus, had their poll been the Changeover Poll, the results would have been:&nbsp; Option 1 and 2:&nbsp; 38%&nbsp; Option 3, 4, and 5:&nbsp; 28%&nbsp; Option 6:&nbsp; 21%&nbsp; Option 7:&nbsp; 11%&nbsp; Or:&nbsp; 307 votes (and 9 additional votes uncountable)&nbsp; Changeover:&nbsp; 38%&nbsp; Partial Changeover:&nbsp; 28%&nbsp; No Changeover:&nbsp; 33%&nbsp; Option 6:&nbsp; 21%&nbsp; The RPGnet poll has turned out, compared to the 2nd Changeover Poll, to have results far more favorable to 4E.&nbsp; Perhaps an *exact* replica of the Changeover Poll (the options being *exactly* the same and interpreted in *exactly* the same way - Options 1 and 2 Changeover, 3/4/5 Partial Changeover, and 6/7 No Changeover) could be placed on RPGnet?&nbsp; However, I cannot be the one to do that.&nbsp; One of you, someone who regularly posts there, should do that.&nbsp; Up to you'all.&nbsp; Edena_of_Neith</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Edena_of_Neith, post: 4630957, member: 2020"] Here are the options in that poll, and their similarity (if any) to the ones here: - Wasn't inspired to try at all (Closest to Option 7, all earlier editions only) - Bought the books but looked crap so never played (Closest to Option 6, tried 4E, returned to earlier editions) - Liked the OP, started off loving but quickly soured (Also closest to Option 6: Tried 4E, returned to earlier editions) - Still playing, rotating with other games/editions (Closest to Options 3, 4, and 5 - Partial Changeover options) - It is still my game of choice and looks to stay that way (Closest to Option 1 (all 4E) and Option 2 (mostly 4E) - Your favourite game sucks (Corresponds with no choice in the Changeover Poll) With that said, their results were: Wasn't inspired to try at all (Equivalent to Option 7) 35 11.08% Bought the books but looked crap so never played (Option 6) 23 7.28% Like the OP, started off loving but quickly soured (Option 6) 42 13.29% Still playing, rotating with other games / editions (Options 3, 4, 5) 87 27.53% It is still my game of choice and looks to stay that way (Options 1, 2) 120 37.97% Your favourite game sucks! 9 2.85% Thus, had their poll been the Changeover Poll, the results would have been: Option 1 and 2: 38% Option 3, 4, and 5: 28% Option 6: 21% Option 7: 11% Or: 307 votes (and 9 additional votes uncountable) Changeover: 38% Partial Changeover: 28% No Changeover: 33% Option 6: 21% The RPGnet poll has turned out, compared to the 2nd Changeover Poll, to have results far more favorable to 4E. Perhaps an *exact* replica of the Changeover Poll (the options being *exactly* the same and interpreted in *exactly* the same way - Options 1 and 2 Changeover, 3/4/5 Partial Changeover, and 6/7 No Changeover) could be placed on RPGnet? However, I cannot be the one to do that. One of you, someone who regularly posts there, should do that. Up to you'all. Edena_of_Neith [/QUOTE]

Verification