Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="jkason" data-source="post: 6260975" data-attributes="member: 2710">Reviewing <a href="http://livingpf.wikia.com/wiki/Menik_(kinem)" target="_blank">Menik</a>:Combat Stats:1) You listed the Iron Liver save bonus, but not the Elf racial one. I added the note for consistency. Feats: 2) Trip bonus for Toppling spell is +11 (lvl 6 + 5 ability). -fixed. Skills: 2) Ability bonus for Craft was wrong. -fixed3) Know: Arcana total was low by 1. - fixed. Spell List (known):4) Hrm. So, RAW, a wizard's spell book does NOT include the cantrips from his opposition schools, which in this case means Menik would have to pay to add Detect Magic (which I see he normally prepares). Our <a href="http://livingpf.wikia.com/wiki/Creating_a_Character" target="_blank">Creating a Character</a> page says "Are not required to begin with all cantrips in their spellbooks (but may do so if they wish, of course)."  Emphasis mine, which kind of makes it sound like we effectively houseruled it, but the <a href="http://www.enworld.org/forum/group.php?discussionid=529&pp=10&page=1&do=discuss" target="_blank">Alternate Cantrip discussion</a> makes clear mention of the exclusion in specialist spellbooks. I'm inclined to say Menik's grandfathered in with his current cantrips, though, given how many levels he's been working this way.  5) It's probably worth knowing that Menik's spell book only has 7 pages left in his current spellbook with the spells as listsed. He'll likely want to pick up a second book in the very near future.Spell List (Prepared):6) Selective should now exclude up to 5 creatures with Menik's current INT - fixed. Adventure Log:7) Adventure log didn't list final XP and GP totals from the most recent adventure. - fixedEquipment / Finances: 8) For some reason, you had 50 gp more in consumed listed in your Finances section than in equipment. I went with the equipment number, since that's what the list of consumed items adds up to. I'm going to throw a question to the General thread about the excluded cantrips, but I don't see a reason to hold up approval any more than it already is for a spell Menik can buy for next to nothing if it comes to it, so I'm going with APPROVED</blockquote>

Verification