3 out of 5 rating for Creature Codex
While
Creature Codex is very similar to
Tome of Beasts and even superior in a few ways, the market of 5th Edition is very different now than when
Tome of Beasts had released. Since mid-2016 we have seen two monster expansions from Wizards of the Coast: there’s simply a lot more monsters in the game. There isn’t as much of a burning need for this product. While
Tome of Beasts quickly became a must-have book that was used every session or two of my home game, I have still used only a small fraction of the content from that book. I doubt
Creature Codex will see as much use. The competition for table time is just higher.
Counting through the monsters of the book, there are 115 or so that I’d use without hesitation, and a few that might be dropped into my game sooner rather than later. And slightly more than that are what I’d consider “okay”: monsters I might use if they fit the story I have in my mind or a fall upon them randomly, but nothing I want to purposely design a story around. That leaves a comparable 110 monsters that are simply “meh”. The monsters I’m unlikely to ever seriously consider. The hit : miss ratio for the book isn’t bad, but it’s worse than Tome of Beasts.
If you’re one of those DMs who thinks you can never have enough monster books, then you should buy
Creature Codex right now with zero hesitation. There’s a few surprises, some nice monsters, and the presentation is solid. Also, if you need monsters right away and
Tome of Beasts is sold out from your FLGS while a copy of
Creature Codex is sitting on the shelf then you will get your money’s worth. It is a good purchase.
But… if you already have
Tome of Beasts you’re probably better off getting one of the other official monster books, such as
Volo’s Guide to Monsters. If you already own those books, then
Creature Codex might be a little superfluous. It’s good, but chances are you haven’t used all the monsters you already own. It’s the monster equivalent of stacking a few new movies onto a Netflix watch list or videogames to your Steam library.
The
Creature Codex is a lovely “extra cash” purchase when you have a few extra bucks from a gift or minor windfall. Especially with fewer official D&D books, it’s a nice option and treat for the ol’ Dungeon Master. It’s nice to have and you won’t regret the purchase, but it’s not so necessary that you have to budget for it right away.
Read my full review
here.