Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Gammadoodler" data-source="post: 9247304" data-attributes="member: 6914290">Sure.. I was aware of the evidence that you didn't cite in any specific way, and still haven't. I'm also aware of previous times you've made this claim, and my previous disagreements with the conclusions you have drawn from it.Looking further into it now.. your assertion that the only caster who &quot;comes close&quot; across all characters.and all seasons is simply and demonstrably false.2nd in total damage for the mighty 9? Fjord..Warlock.. also with fewer episodes of combat participation than Beau.Current damage leader in Bells Hells on both a total and average basis..Imogen..SorcererDamage leader on an average basis Vox Machina, Tiberius (Sorcerer) and then Keyleth (Druid) (though to be fair, I'm not at all sure how the VM stats are organized. It doesn't seem to be by episode).As far as your justification of Caleb's status as an exception, it's also false..Damage dealing wasn't Caleb's whole thing. He was a transmutation wizard. His most used leveled spell was Alarm..Followed by Tiny Hut..Followed by Identify..followed by Polymorph..Followed by Detect Magic..Followed by Fortune's Favor..Followed by Mage Armor and Shield..Followed by Teleportation Circle and Comprehend Languages..And only after all of those do we get to Fireball. Hell, he cast Polymorph almost as many times as he cast alllll damaging leveled spells... And yet..more kills and close in damage (with fewer combats).So yes, I find your interpretation shallow.. which is more generous than &quot;wrong&quot;. I stand by it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Gammadoodler, post: 9247304, member: 6914290"] Sure.. I was aware of the evidence that you didn't cite in any specific way, and still haven't. I'm also aware of previous times you've made this claim, and my previous disagreements with the conclusions you have drawn from it. Looking further into it now.. your assertion that the only caster who "comes close" across all characters.and all seasons is simply and demonstrably false. 2nd in total damage for the mighty 9? Fjord..Warlock.. also with fewer episodes of combat participation than Beau. Current damage leader in Bells Hells on both a total and average basis..Imogen..Sorcerer Damage leader on an average basis Vox Machina, Tiberius (Sorcerer) and then Keyleth (Druid) (though to be fair, I'm not at all sure how the VM stats are organized. It doesn't seem to be by episode). As far as your justification of Caleb's status as an exception, it's also false..Damage dealing wasn't Caleb's whole thing. He was a transmutation wizard. His most used leveled spell was Alarm..Followed by Tiny Hut..Followed by Identify..followed by Polymorph..Followed by Detect Magic..Followed by Fortune's Favor..Followed by Mage Armor and Shield..Followed by Teleportation Circle and Comprehend Languages..And only after all of those do we get to Fireball. Hell, he cast Polymorph almost as many times as he cast alllll damaging leveled spells... And yet..more kills and close in damage (with fewer combats). So yes, I find your interpretation shallow.. which is more generous than "wrong". I stand by it. [/QUOTE]

Verification