d20M Brawl/Combat Martial Arts

[Goose]

According to the rules, Brawl allows you to deal 1d6 unarmed/nonlethal damage, now this attack is still considered unarmed so you provoke an AoO. Now if i had the combat Martial Arts feat, it treats my fists as weapons that do 1d4 thats either lethal or not. Now if i stacked these feats would i do the 1d6 armed lethal/non? Or would you as the DM allow Brawl to be considered armed but nonlethal?

 

[Dismas]

On the WoTC d20 Modern boards Charles Ryan has said that they do not stack. You either use Brawl or CMA for your attack, but not both.

 

[Bagpuss]

Hmm, like non-lethal damage didn't suck enough already now you have to suffer an attack of opportunity to deal enough damage to stand a small chance of knocking someone out.

 

[bwgwl]

i'd probably let them partially stack. i.e., if you have both, you could do 1d6 nonlethal or 1d4 lethal, and neither would provoke an attack of opportunity.