Thanee
First Post
One thing to think about... using 3rd person is IMHO superior to using 1st person for some reasons.
Right now, with one post per character, it doesn't really matter, but later you will certainly describe things to some or all characters at the same time, then it might get rather confusing what "you" refers to. Being able to actually refer to the characters by name might greatly enhance this.
Also 3rd person reads more consistent and fluent, at least to me.
In the last paragraph of the "Melody post" you even switch between 1st and 3rd person, midsentence...
I really think using purely 3rd person is the best way to go.
Bye
Thanee
Right now, with one post per character, it doesn't really matter, but later you will certainly describe things to some or all characters at the same time, then it might get rather confusing what "you" refers to. Being able to actually refer to the characters by name might greatly enhance this.
Also 3rd person reads more consistent and fluent, at least to me.

In the last paragraph of the "Melody post" you even switch between 1st and 3rd person, midsentence...

I really think using purely 3rd person is the best way to go.
Bye
Thanee