Dilemma time! Help?

[blargney the second]

Drop him to negatives, dip him in poo, use him as an improvised ranged weapon against the other PCs.

 

[werk]

Another vote for let him die. You're not going out of your way or trying to kill him. You might give him a get out of jail free card for missing the sense motive rolls, but it's pretty likely they would have failed those anyway unless you have a bard...oh, right.

Depends on a lot of things, I guess, but I'd probably kill him. That's how they learn.

 

[The Lost Muse]

I would allow the bard to make a bluff check and feign death (talking is a free action, as is dropping stuff). IF the otugyh falls for it, he'll probably drop the bard, and move closer (ending its turn). On the bards turn, he could attempt to fascinate the creature, or just run for it.

 

[gizmo33]

I would allow the bard to make a bluff check and feign death (talking is a free action, as is dropping stuff). IF the otugyh falls for it, he'll probably drop the bard, and move closer (ending its turn). On the bards turn, he could attempt to fascinate the creature, or just run for it.

I don't know much about Otyughs, but if I'm eating a hamburger, the first thing I check for is to make sure it's dead. At that point it doesn't really matter if the hamburger is bluffing or not. My next action is not to move closer per se, since I already have a hold of the hamburger, my next action is to maintain the grapple and put it in my mouth, biting off a big chunk of it. If other hamburgers are circling me and trying to stab me with their swords, I'd probably keep them at bay with my free hand unless it were holding a soda, in which case I'd kick at them and keep chewing. What I wouldn't do, unless I weren't hungry, would be to put down the hamburger in order to argue with the other hamburgers. Then again, why would I bother attacking a hamburger in the first place if I wasn't hungry?

I don't know how good of a singer my hamburger would have to be in order to fascinate me. Though I suppose if I put it down, I would be expecting it to sing to me.

(Edit: reminds me of that big monster in Return of Jedi. He was chasing around Luke and that squealy orc monster. He caught the squealy orc monster and rather than slapping it around until it pretended to be dead, I think he just ate it for his round.)

 

[funkysnunkulator]

yon character shall die most heinously. cause the players are stupid.

when adventuring, paranoia levels should be high. letting a party member walk away without backup?

not cool boo boo.

 

[Philotomy Jurament]

Roll the dice. See what happens.